IT IS no surprise that the Bishops' Pastoral Letter for the
General Election should have drawn a largely negative Conservative
response, and virtual silence from everyone else.
Labour, the Lib Dems, and the Greens don't want to be seen to
endorse anything from the Church. As for the Tories, you have only
to combine the word "poverty" with the word "bishop" to produce
howls of left-wing bias, and demands that the Church stick to
saving souls and stop interfering in politics.
Even The Times, normally more balanced, produced a
ridiculous leader describing the letter as "disingenuous and, in at
least half a dozen respects, nakedly partisan".
This hysterical over-judgement is not justified. The most
important point that the Bishops make is about the culture of
present-day politics: the lack of any attempt by the parties to
sketch a moral vision for society. Instead, they are presenting
themselves as rival brands, with voters as mere consumers. Their
election promises are bribes aimed at particular interest groups;
there is no appeal to the nation as a whole. The Bishops are right
to point out that all this undermines democracy, and produces the
kind of cynical despair in which extremism can all too easily take
root.
They are also right to emphasise the importance of social
cohesion, and to draw attention to the plight of the poor. They
could hardly be Christian if they failed to do this. It is
extraordinary, not to say alarming, that Tories see this as the
inevitable mark of a left-wing bias. There was a time when Tories
were proud to be concerned for social justice, and were often
better than their more ideologically driven rivals at delivering
imaginative policies that helped poor people. It is still likely
that Iain Duncan Smith's reforms to the benefits system will
achieve that, reducing unemployment and encouraging people back to
work. Michael Gove's war on the complacent teaching unions was an
attempt to get justice for all children in the education system, no
matter how poor their background or narrow their family
horizons.
The Tories should have replied to the Bishops' letter by
articulating the moral vision that they can genuinely claim: a
passion for freedom within the law; a respect for individual
flourishing in which all have a chance to reach their potential;
and the concern for community cohesion which lay behind "the Big
Society".
If the Tories were interested in the votes of the million or so
people who claim to be Anglicans, they would have come out
fighting. If it is not possible to vote Conservative
because you believe in justice and fairness, then our
political system really is in trouble.