IT SAYS a great deal about the power of forgiveness and the
spirit of reconciliation that the square in Warsaw in which the
Monument to the Ghetto Heroes stands should be named after a former
West German Chancellor. Also that a concert by the Israel Symphony
Orchestra in the city, to mark the 70th anniversary of the
uprising, should be of music by a German composer.
As the Nazi conquest took hold, Jews were gathered together in
ghettoes throughout Eastern Europe - walled districts that were, in
effect, holding camps before transportation to the death camps.
Yad Vashem, the Holocaust research, education, and memorial
centre in Jerusalem, estimates that the population of the Warsaw
Ghetto, at its height, ranged from 470,000 to 590,000.
The first transportations to the Treblinka death camp began in
July 1942. It is estimated that just 55,000 to 60,000 Jews remained
in the Ghetto when the uprising began on the eve of Passover, 19
April 1943.
Fearful that the final deportations were about to begin, the
remaining inhabitants decided that they were not going to die
quietly. They had two important factors in their favour: the
element of surprise, and a strength that comes when a community is
fighting for its very existence. But the outcome was inevitable:
about 13,000 Jews were killed during the two-week uprising; and
most of the 50,000 or so who remained were transported to the death
camps. A few managed to escape, using the city's sewers and
tunnels.
The end came on 16 May 1943, when SS-Gruppenführer Jürgen Stroop
concluded the burning of the Ghetto by blowing up the city's Grand
Synagogue.
A modern tower of offices now stands on the site. The
synagogue's neighbouring library survived, and now houses a Jewish
institution. Scorch marks are still visible on its stone floor.
IT IS considered politically correct to think about ordinary
Germans as victims of Hitler's Nazi ideology and regime. But not in
Warsaw. Too many Germans were involved to put the blame on an
extremist minority.
The message from those who survive, and those who cherish the
memories of the victims, is clear: the Holocaust was only possible
on mainland Europe in the 20th century because whole nations had
become poisoned by hatred of the Jews.
A host of dignitaries attended the Thursday-evening concert,
among them various ambassadors; the Israeli Education Minister,
Rabbi Shai Piron; and the President of Poland, Bronisław
Komorowski. But the biggest cheer came when it was announced that
Symcha Ratajzer-Rotem, or Kazik, as he is better known - one of the
three participants in the uprising still alive - had travelled from
his home in Jerusalem to attend.
Aged 89, and quite frail, he was the only one of the three who
was well enough to travel to the commemorations.
Beethoven featured prominently in the programme: his overture to
Egmont, the Violin Concerto in D Major, and the Fifth
Symphony.
ON FRIDAY, the commemorations moved to Willy Brandt Square, named
after the former West German Chancellor who, in 1970, unexpectedly
knelt at the Monument to the Ghetto Heroes during a visit. He said
later: "Under the weight of recent history, I did what people do
when words fail; so I thought of millions murdered."
Representatives of numerous governments around the world,
including the UK Under Secretary of State for Communities and Local
Government, Don Foster MP, joined military, religious, and civil
leaders for a ceremony of remembrance at the memorial, which had
been built after the war, using stones brought to Poland by the
Nazis to celebrate the expected German victory.
Mr Ratajzer-Rotem was here again, too: this time to receive a
state honour from the Polish President - the Order of the Cross of
Polish Restoration.
He told the audience: "To this very day, I keep thinking whether
we had the right to make the decision to start the uprising; and by
the same token to shorten the lives of many people by a week, a day
or two. Nobody gave us the authorisation to do that; and that is
the doubt that I have to live with.
"Despite all their cruelty, the Germans did not manage to break
the moral framework of the Jewish society: in spite of the fact
that they forced half a million people into a single district of
Warsaw; in spite of the fact that they did not allow us to work; in
spite of famine or disease that resulted in 100,000 people dying;
in spite of the constant intimidations, repressions, and
murder."
CHURCH bells rang, and sirens sounded across Warsaw to mark the
start of the service of remembrance. Prayers were said by Roman
Catholic, Orthodox, and Lutheran chaplains to the Polish Army. The
Chief Rabbi of Poland recited the Kaddish; and Cantor Joseph
Malovany sang the El Male Rachamim.
The VIPs laid wreaths at the memorial - many made of daffodils,
which have become the symbol of Ghetto remembrance in Warsaw. A
march then took place to the Umschlagplatz Memorial - the site of
the station where many were herded on to trains taking them to the
death camps.
During the anniversary commemorations, the Museum of the History
of Polish Jews was opened, marking the start of the museum's
cultural and educational outreach work. The core exhibition is
still being completed: a grand opening will take place next
year.
Before the Second World War, more than one third of Warsaw's
population was Jewish, in a country of more than 3.3 million Jews.
By the end of the war, more than 90 per cent had been killed.
The museum faces the Monument to the Ghetto Heroes. Its brochure
states: "The monument commemorates how Jews died, while the museum
memorialises how they lived."