THE difficulty of
inviting the whole class to a birthday party is the least of a
school's worries. A note from the head teacher of Kingswood Prep
School, Bath, touched only on invitations given out in class. It
would be unchristian, he told parents, to exclude anyone. Parents,
mostly from other schools, have expressed their views. This,
however, has been a minor spat. Elsewhere, schools have found
themselves on the country's religious faultline, confronting issues
of custom and faith which society finds intractable. The latest
incident involved two Muslim 14-year-olds excluded from Mount
Carmel RC School, Accrington, in Lancashire, for starting to grow
beards. The head teacher took advice and concluded that the beards
were non-essential to Islam. More advice followed, and the boys
were allowed back on condition that their decision to stop shaving
was related to the Hafiz programme of Muslim instruction. In
another example of Lancashire accommodation, Witton Park High
School, Blackburn, closed for three days this week so that pupils,
half of them non-Muslims, could celebrate Eid. Pupils had ended the
summer holidays three days early to allow for this. At the time of
writing, the Al-Madinah School in Derby was awaiting the
publication of the emergency OFSTED report, after the resignation
of a teacher who said she was pressured to wear a hijab, and tales
that certain subjects had been banned. And inspectors are in
negotiations with an Orthodox Jewish school in Hackney, London,
where GCSE science papers are said to have been doctored to prevent
pupils' answering questions about evolution.
The picture is confusing,
inevitably, as schools attempt to find local solutions to a
widespread set of challenges. It has been suggested that much of
the confusion is caused by the poor grasp of Christianity now
permeating the education world, which thus leaves a vacuum to be
filled by other faiths and customs. Certainly, the teaching of
religion, and Christianity in particular, has deteriorated very
quickly, as highlighted by OFSTED last week. But Christianity ought
not to seen as a bulwark against "alien" practices and beliefs. A
strong Christian presence in a school ought, we believe, prompt an
intelligent welcome to those of other religions who wish to express
their faith in some way - just as the schools expect, and receive,
approval from those of other faiths when they plan events from the
Christian calendar, such as nativity plays. The likelihood is that
national policy will be influenced by these particular local
decisions: policy-making by case law. But it is hard to see any
other way to proceed. Schools have different personalities,
histories, pupil intakes, and so on, and are in the best place to
judge when tolerance can be exercised and when uniformity needs to
be enforced.
It would be dangerous if a school were unduly influenced by an
extremist element within one of the faiths. But the recent attempt
by the National Secular Society to discredit church schools because
of a supposed extremist element was dismissed by a spokesman for
the Education Secretary for lack of evidence. British schools are,
on the whole, robust institutions, able to resist undue pressure
from undemocratic forces.