THE film industry has been looking for a worthy successor to
Harry Potter and the Twilight series for a couple of years. In the
shape of the Hunger Games trilogy, perhaps it finally has films
that cross over from the teen to the adult demographic. The second
film in the series, Catching Fire, is released today, and
for Christians interested in how popular culture relates to faith,
it offers a theological feast.
Based on the novels of Suzanne Collins, the Hunger Games trilogy
stars the Oscar-winner Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen, a
teenage girl facing impossible challenges in a dystopic future.
Katniss lives in Panem, a country that succeeds a war-destroyed
United States, and is ruled by the wealthy and decadent inhabitants
of the Capitol and the manipulative President Snow. Like most
"citizens", she lives under an oppressive system, which forces her
to provide cheap goods for the Capitol.
Every year, the Capitol maintains its control by selecting two
teenagers from each outlying district to act as tributes, who are
then forced to fight to the death in an event entitled the Hunger
Games. The story follows Katniss's battle to survive as a tribute,
and bring down the oppressive system of Panem.
From a Christian point of view, part of the fascination of the
Hunger Games lies in the fact that it seems such unpromising
material. Whereas Harry Potter, for example, was clearly grounded
in a narrative of sacrificial love, the Hunger Games is bleaker
fare. It is unsentimental about the fact that, in a world based on
exploitation and repression, young people will be offered up as
victims.
For a children's book, it might seem to have more in common with
Game of Thrones than Harry Potter (
Comment, 14 June). Yet it offers a striking vision of what hope
and faith might look like in appalling times.
THE heroine Katniss is that rarest thing in fantasy literature -
an impressively active, courageous, and inspiring young woman; she
is a fine Christian and feminist role-model.
Despite the seeming absence of religion in her world, she
presents a powerful Christian example in her preparedness to lay
down her life for the sake of others. She volunteers to be a
tribute in place of her sister, in the knowledge that in doing so,
the odds of her survival are negligible.
Equally, when she is in the combat arena, she subverts the cruel
system on several occasions. She demonstrates love and compassion
towards the youngest participant in the games, Rue, by singing to
her, after Rue is mortally wounded. Katniss gives her dignity in
death by covering her in flowers.
At the end of the first book, when Katniss and a fellow tribute
are expected to fight to the death, she manufactures a situation in
which both will die rather than be a winner. Her willingness to
sacrifice herself ultimately forces the system to declare them both
"winners".
She is a strong feminist icon, too. Whereas the heroine of the
Twilight novels, Bella Swan, seems intent only on pleasing her
man/vampire, Katniss is, at 17, effectively the head of her
household. She provides for her sick, bereaved mother, and is
practical and responsible, without succumbing to self-pity.
Her survival skills, developed in the harsh conditions of the
Appalachian Mountains, become crucial to her success in the Hunger
Games. Unlike many female heroines, she does not rely on looks or
popularity to succeed.
CHRISTIANITY has often struggled to provide strong, active images
of women; so often, they have been characterised as plaster saints
or wicked sinners in need of redemption.
If Katniss is an icon of Christ, she also connects with a
biblical tradition of women such as Martha. While Martha has
typically been seen as someone overly focused on domestic tasks,
some critics have argued that she was actually the head of her
household.
If this was the case, and she was charged with responsibility
for Mary and Lazarus, her practical responses become more
impressive.
Like Katniss, Martha is honest and direct. When Jesus fails to
show up for Lazarus's funeral (John 11), it is Martha who points
out this failure on Jesus's part. She represents the costs that
women who take charge and responsibility face, in a society set up
for male power.
AS A Christian, one might be cautious about celebrating Katniss's
acts of violence - she kills a number of people - but she is not so
different from the biblical character of Deborah.
Deborah fulfils many roles in pre-monarchical Israel - judge and
prophet, as well as warrior and leader. She successfully leads a
counter-attack against Jabin, the Canaanite king.
Even if we rightly question the historical accuracy of Old
Testament accounts, the story of Deborah is one of a strong
independent woman, leading her people in a fight against an
oppressive regime. As a prophet, she reminds Israel of its call to
be faithful to the living God.
Katniss is a young woman thrown by circumstance into the
position of being a figure of hope. Despite her very human doubts,
and the fact that she abhors violence, she becomes the focal point
for resistance in Panem. She reminds the oppressed people that they
are called to follow a path of justice and respect for the
weakest.
Social justice is one of the crucial aspects of Christianity,
although sometimes, because of the Church's anxious focus on
reversing declining influence and numbers, the call to such justice
gets lost. The story of Katniss Everdeen is a parable that reminds
us why we should never lose sight of it.
If the Hunger Games is sometimes unsubtle, its picture of a
world in which a small number of people live lives of
self-indulgent luxury by exploiting the resources of the majority
is a potent one. Even if we in the countries of the North are not
quite as obsessed with show, fame, and maintaining our comfort as
the people in Panem's Capitol, we are not far off.
As Christians, we are constantly being called to pay attention
to God's hunger for justice. Thankfully, we do not live in a
society that maintains its position by forcing groups of young
people to fight to the death, but we should not hide from the
exploitation inherent in our system.
Our clothes, food, and privilege are maintained at enormous cost
to the majority in the world. The young - as in our own society -
bear the excess weight of that exploitation. Our call as Christians
is to stand with the Katniss Everdeens of our world.
The Revd Rachel Mann is Priest-in-Charge of St Nicholas's,
Burnage, Manchester, poet-in-residence at Manchester Cathedral, and
the author of The Risen Dust (Wild Goose, 2013).