*** DEBUG START ***
*** DEBUG END ***

Mark D’Arcy: The era of two-party politics is over

03 October 2025

The Government faces an uphill struggle to win back voters, says Mark D’Arcy

Alamy

Nigel Farage reacts to Sir Keir Starmer’s speech to the Labour Party Conference, on Tuesday

Nigel Farage reacts to Sir Keir Starmer’s speech to the Labour Party Conference, on Tuesday

PARTY-CONFERENCE season 2025 is the shop window for new multi-party politics in Britain. Fed up with Sir Keir? Try Zac Polanski’s new “eco-populist” Greens, or maybe Jeremy Corbyn’s as-yet-unnamed new party of the Left. Or, if your complaint is that Labour should get on with rejoining the EU, maybe Ed Davey’s Lib Dems? After all, they’re the biggest third-party grouping in the Commons for 100 years.

Normally, when a Labour government is in the doldrums, the Conservatives would scoop up disaffected voters; but Kemi Badenoch, heir to the most successful and longest-lived political party in history, finds herself in the relegation zone, struggling to avoid demotion to the minor league of politics.

Instead, the beneficiary is Nigel Farage's Reform UK — poised for a commanding parliamentary majority on perhaps one third of the vote, if the polls are to be believed. Veterans of the 1980s will recall how an earlier insurgent party, the SDP, briefly appeared destined to break the political mould, before fading at a General Election; but the game is different now, and it is far from pre-ordained that Mr Farage will suffer the same fate. The simplicities of the old two-party choice have been replaced by a bewildering variety of offerings.

So, how might this novel new politics play out? Labour, having shed one third of the voters who put them in power last year, hopes to lure them back with a “patriotic renewal”, which will include a national identity card to clamp down on illegal migration, and a “Build, Baby, Build” planning policy to create new towns and new housing, to offer Generation Z the prospect of home ownership. But they will also have to maintain eye-wateringly tight spending limits on public services and, probably, take another stab at welfare reform.

The harbinger of that last policy was the appointment of Pat McFadden as Work and Pensions Secretary in the recent government reshuffle. The Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, desperately needs to rein in welfare spending, but the political difficulty of cutting benefits was demonstrated by the twin fiascos over the pensioners’ winter fuel payments and the benefits-cut revolt by Labour MPs. Enter the wily Mr McFadden, a fixer with a pedigree stretching back to Tony Blair’s Downing Street, appointed as the man most likely to achieve serious savings. Much will now depend on those political skills.

The Government needs to win positive marks for both technical merit and artistic impression from several unforgiving judging panels: the bond markets are already nervous about the level of public borrowing, and crisis looms if they decisively lose faith; Labour MPs are close to despair over the performance of their leadership and their personal prospect of re-election; and the voters themselves will have an opportunity to register their verdict in elections for the Scottish Parliament, then the Welsh Sennedd and English metropolitan councils in May 2026.

A negative verdict from any of those judges could produce another spasm of political chaos.

Mark D’Arcy co-presents the Hansard Society’s podcast, Parliament Matters.

Paul Vallely is away.

Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Letters to the editor

Letters for publication should be sent to letters@churchtimes.co.uk.

Letters should be exclusive to the Church Times, and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear below your letter unless requested otherwise.

Forthcoming Events

Church Times Festival of Preaching 2026

13 - 15 September 2026

An event to inspire, nurture, and celebrate all who are called to proclaim the gospel today.

tickets available now

English Mystics Series course

26 January - 25 May 2026

A short course at Sarum College.

tickets available now

 

This year, the Church Times is also delighted to sponsor two events: 

National Cathedrals Conference  Bristol, 18 to 21 May 2026

An event aimed at developing cathedrals as important places of prayer, inspiration, education, challenge, and debate. Find out more at nationalcathedralsconference.org

Public Faith Common Good  a day symposium at St John’s College Cambridge, Tuesday 21 July 2026

Speakers to include the former Archbishop of Canterbury Lord Williams; the Bishop of Chelmsford, Dr Guli Francis-Deqhani, Nick Spencer, and Anna Rowlands.

This event is free, but booking is required. Find out more at elydatabase.org/events

 

Visit our Events page for upcoming and past events

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times

To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

New to us? Non-subscribers can read up to four free articles a month. Simply sign up for a free account to receive the Church Times newsletter, plus exclusive offers and events, straight to your inbox. As a thank you for joining us, we are also currently offering a £5 discount for the Church House Bookshop online (valid for one order of £30 or more). See your welcome email for details.