*** DEBUG END ***

Press: Jonathan Fletcher’s victims speak out

03 January 2020


THERE is a thesis to be written on the role of cold water in the construction of upper-class masculinity: Ice baths and the English imagina­tion, perhaps. James Bond is the most famous recent practitioner: taking cold showers after hot baths enabled him to overcome the effects of 60 unfiltered Turkish cigarettes and half a bottle of hard booze every day.

But, before him, there was the more attract­ive figure of Lord Peter Wimsey, who on his wedding night was “scrubbed like a puppy under the scullery pump” by his devoted butler after the heating failed and before he went up to his bride. In that instance, the cold water failed to quench his ardour at all.

And some long way down the line of de­­scent of upper-class Christians comes the Revd Jonathan Fletcher, former Minister of Em­­manuel Ridgway Proprietary Chapel, Wimble­don, a man who separated himself and his fol­lowers almost entirely from the Church of England because he was so horrified by its sexual immorality.

Mr Fletcher made the front page of the Daily Telegraph the day after Boxing Day, when five of his former congregants discussed his ways of enthusing the congregation. Gabriella Swerling’s story, though a very late entrant, may have scampered away with the reward for the paragraph of the year: “It was only after Victim A was stood naked in the bathroom of one of the Church of England’s leading evan­­gelical preachers, the Rev Jonathan Fletcher, that he became aware that this would not just be a cold bath, but an ice bath. Nor would he be alone.”

The ice baths, some taken fully clothed, have now been added to the record of be­havi­our which Mr Fletcher described as “light-hearted forfeits” when they first came to light in the summer (News, 5 July). These, accord­ing to the church’s own statement, included beating with gym shoes, and “one-to-one massage, ranging from partially clothed mas­sage to massage where both men are said to have been fully naked throughout and to have taken turns to massage each other. Again, this conduct seems to have become a regular part of the relationship between Jonathan and cer­tain men over a period of time.”

Cold showers and beating with gym shoes were a formative part of my own education at an otherwise excellent prep school in the late ’60s. Being beaten with a gym shoe was ex­­tremely painful and humiliating, as it was in­­tended to be, when I was eight. I cannot ima­gine what might cause an adult to submit to it. But the oddest thing of all is the description of these activities as “light-hearted”.

They were, after all, intended to teach lessons of the first importance: how to bear bravely both pain and the certain prospect of pain; how to transform humiliation into an inward acceptance of authority; and, not least, the importance of competent criminality and of not getting caught. Some of these are genu­ine virtues, and all of them are improve­ments on resentment and self-pity. But they are none of them light-hearted, even in re-enactment. And, even aged eight, we all knew that some of the masters enjoyed beating us very much more than they should.


AND so to lighter things. Gavin Ashenden announced his departure from the Church of England in the Mail on Sunday: “Sadly, I have come to the conclusion that in some important respects Britain is starting to resemble Soviet-era Eastern Europe. Freedom of speech is slowly being eroded; those who refuse to be ‘politically correct’ risk accusations of thought crime and Christians are being unfairly per­secuted. . . I now believe only the Catholic church has the courage, integrity and convic­tion to hold the Christian ground.

”If we give way any further, we risk another Iron Curtain. Only this time, it will separate the Christian East from the Marxist West — and we will be on the wrong side.”

Let’s all hope this performance earns him a lucrative gig on the TV network Russia Today, expounding the Christian virtues of President Putin.


SINCE I no longer write leaders for The Guardian, I can now safely mention them in this column, and their Christmas one had come a very long distance from the Dawkinsian orthodoxy of 20 years ago. “The battle to defend the rights and human dignity of all, irrespective of gender, race or sexuality, is having to be fought all over again. But the theological roots of that liberal vision in a Pauline notion of universality — ‘all are one in Christ’ — is rarely examined by progressives. In an era when Christian ethics are being so brazenly twisted to serve nativism and attacks on minorities, that could be a mistake.”


THERE are two celebrated writers named Rowan who live close to one another in Cam­bridge, but only one is the former editor of Erotic Review. Rowan Pelling, for it is she, had a lovely piece in praise of late baptisms in the Telegraph. Her son is 11, and she feels that she can put the ceremony off no longer. “It’s the best excuse for a big, jolly mid-life party with­out having to remarry or tell the whole world your precise age.”

Letters to the editor

Letters for publication should be sent to letters@churchtimes.co.uk.

Letters should be exclusive to the Church Times, and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear alongside your letter.

Forthcoming Events

6-7 September 2022
Preaching as Pilgrimage conference
From the College of Preachers.

27-28 September 2022
humbler church Bigger God conference
The HeartEdge Conference in Manchester includes the Theology Slam Live Final.

More events

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four* articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)

*Until the end of June: we’re doubling the number of free articles to eight, to celebrate the publication of our Platinum Jubilee double issue.