*** DEBUG END ***

Cathedrals and churches plan ‘alternative’ Christmas carol services and festivities

20 November 2020

Uncertainty about levels of restriction will mean managing expectations, says RSCM


Andy Fearon, of the Vineyard Church, Carlisle, is supporting the “Big Carol Sing” in Cumbria on 20 December. BBC Radio Cumbria will broadcast a special programme from 6 p.m. that evening. People will be asked to sing “Silent night” on their doorsteps at 6.15 p.m.

Andy Fearon, of the Vineyard Church, Carlisle, is supporting the “Big Carol Sing” in Cumbria on 20 December. BBC Radio Cumbria will broadcast a specia...

PLANNING Christmas carol services amid the ongoing uncertainty about levels of restriction will mean managing expectations and “working from possibility-plus rather than wishful-thinking-minus”, the director of the Royal School of Church Music (RSCM), Hugh Morris, suggests.

Despite no prospect yet of congregational singing — certainly not in the “lung-busting way that we are used to” — there were still many possibilities for physically coming together, he said. Cathedrals were still potentially able to assemble some musicians where there were professional singers; lay clerks were potentially able to meet; and those with boarding-choir schools could use their trebles. Larger churches, too, with uncharacteristically clear diaries, had scope to do multiple carol services for a small number over a long period of time.

That is happening at Truro Cathedral, where tickets went on release this week for a daily one-hour offering of carols, “O Holy Night”, by the cathedral choir, as part of the week-long Christmas Festival that begins on 4 December. It comes with the proviso that events will be cancelled if the lockdown is extended.

Winchester Cathedral is also advertising multiple carol concerts and a “Big Nativity” before Christmas; further details are to be announced.

The churches of the Major Churches Network (MCN) were prepared for a “likely worst-case scenario” that would mean they would open only for live streaming, without a congregation; but they were hoping for “a best we can hope for” with a reduced one, the MCN’s chairman, Canon Chris Newlands, who is the Vicar of Lancaster Priory, said on Monday.

“For many cathedrals and major parish churches, this will be devastating on so many levels,” he said. “We will not be able to host the carol services for schools, town and city councils, and local charities such as hospices, which raise large amounts of money for them, and give us the opportunity to form excellent bonds with our local partners in serving the local communities where we are based.”

But, despite all this, planning for the seasons of Advent and Christmas was going ahead, he said. Canon Newlands said that Lancaster Priory, would be recording an Advent Sunday carol service with contributions from the Roman Catholic cathedral, the Methodist church, and the Elim church, to make it “a service for the city from its churches. . .

“We continue to plan most of our usual Christmas services, hoping that we will be able to live-stream them even if no congregation can be present. At least people have not been banned from singing carols in their own homes. Following a live-streamed midnight mass or Service of Nine Lessons and Carols, they would be able to join in singing the familiar Christmas hymns and carols, free from face masks and in the company of their closest family members, and at liberty to raise their voices to sing “Glory to the newborn King”.

Advent Sunday, on 29 November, falls within the lockdown period. The Church in Wales launched an Advent campaign, Darkness Into Light, on Tuesday: its six cathedrals and greater churches will light up after dark on Advent Sunday to “stand out as beacons in their towns and cities as a powerful symbol that, even when their doors have had to close, or traditional services have been unable to take place, the Church is still present in and serving the community”.

Church in Wales bishops are inviting people to join them in a prayer for the nation every day in Advent. They are inviting people of all faiths and traditions to pray with them every evening at six from Advent Sunday to Christmas Day. Their prayer asks for God’s healing and blessing on Wales during times of darkness, such as the pandemic. In addition, the people of Wales are asked to revive an old Welsh tradition of carol-singing from home. Everyone is encouraged to sing “Silent night” on their doorsteps at 7 p.m. on Christmas Eve.

The Church of England’s digital and print campaign “Comfort and Joy(News, 9 October) “holds together the hope that Christmas will bring joy and celebration after a uniquely difficult year with an acknowledgement that — for those who have lost loved ones or livelihoods, or who are potentially still not able to be together with loved ones — it may be the Church’s role, both nationally and locally, to provide consolation, rather than assume everybody will be ready to join in jubilation”.

It includes nine online services throughout Advent and Christmas, including a Christingle with the Children’s Society, and Nine Lessons and Carols and midnight services, produced in collaboration with charities including Christian Aid, Church Army, Embrace, and Marie Curie.

Speakers on a downloadable RSCM webinar, “What are we going to do this Christmas?”, emphasised that the key for Advent and Christmas was the simplicity of the gospel message and the brevity of any service: a maximum of 45 minutes, so that people were not too long indoors together.

“There are as many solutions as there are situations,” Mr Morris said. “The best practice is going with what you know is possible, and making something of that, rather than planning a lot of things that might not happen and lead to frustration.”

The head of ministerial training at the RCSM, the Revd Helen Bent, has produced a service, “A village Christmas during the Covid-19 pandemic”. It retains the traditional elements of a Nine Lessons and Carols service, but is deliberately short, and can be used in church, outside in a communal space, or online. “A Christmas congregation comes with the expectation that the service will include plenty of carols — and, indeed, a service without music will lack cheer,” Ms Bent says.

“Although congregational singing is unlikely to be allowed under current government restrictions, live music can be provided by a small group of singers suitably positioned and socially distanced.”

Mr Morris hopes that the RSCM’s Big Christmas Carol Service, on 12 December, will also be of great support, as “a way of showing solidarity with each other and coming together. Singing alone in your living room isn’t as good [as singing together], but it’s singing,” he said.

Christmas events are well into the planning, too. Worcester Cathedral promises “a glittering avenue of Christmas trees” in its medieval cloister, each one designed and decorated by local businesses, charities, and schools; all the profits will go towards the running of the cathedral.

Ely Cathedral’s Virtual Christmas Fair includes carols by its choristers, and is designed to “bring some much-needed joy as well as an opportunity for some shopping”, the events manager, Joss Palmer, said.

“So many of our exhibitors are relatively small and independent businesses who rely on these large-scale events and seasonal sales for their livelihood, and it is important that we are able to support them at such a challenging time.”

And the spirit of Christmas echoed in the carol “Good King Wenceslas” remains alive and well in the charities working with those hardest hit by the pandemic. Some, such as the Fund for Human Need (FHN), is distributing more money than at any time in its history, with a surge in demand and a doubling of requests for help.

The charity is proving a lifeline to one particular group: those with “no recourse to public funds”. They include women suffering from domestic violence, and others who need to replace papers stolen while they were living on the streets.

Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Forthcoming Events

Green Church Awards

Awards Ceremony: 6 September 2024

Read more details about the awards


Festival of Preaching

15-17 September 2024

The festival moves to Cambridge along with a sparkling selection of expert speakers

tickets available



Festival of Faith and Literature

28 February - 2 March 2025

The festival programme is soon to be announced sign up to our newsletter to stay informed about all festival news.

Festival website


ViSIt our Events page for upcoming and past events 

Welcome to the Church Times


To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)