Consecration of GAFCON bishop in new NZ Church is criticised

25 October 2019

GAFCON

THE consecration of a bishop of a new Church of Confessing Anglicans in New Zealand, welcomed by synods in Australia, is a sign that the schism in the Anglican Communion is speeding up, the Bishop of Christchurch, Dr Peter Carrell, has suggested.

The two Archbishops of the Anglican Church in Aotearoa, New Zealand & Polynesia (ACNZP) have described the presence of bishops in communion with their Church, who had not informed them before crossing boundaries, as “disturbing”. They are planning an “appropriate protest”.

The Virtue Online website reports that 650 people attended the consecration of the Revd Douglas (Jay) Behan as the first bishop of the Church of Confessing Anglicans Aotearoa, New Zealand (CCAANZ), a local expression of the GAFCON movement, at Centennial Chapel, St Andrew’s College, Christchurch, on Saturday.

It was conducted by 16 bishops and archbishops, including the Archbishop of Sydney, Dr Glenn Davies, and the Bishop of Tasmania, Dr Richard Condie. The synods of both Sydney and Melbourne have welcomed Mr Behan’s appointment.

“Is this the moment . . . when the fracture in the Anglican Communion becomes irreversible?” Bishop Carrell asked the Archbishop of Canterbury in a message posted on Twitter on Saturday. “Australian bishops out of protocol control, two of their synods greeting a breakaway diocese. Archbishops from Rwanda, Australia and ACNA combine to inaugurate a new Anglican Church!”

On Monday, he said that there was a “range of reactions” to the consecration in his diocese. The failure of bishops in the Communion to inform the diocese of their intention to minister there was “bewildering to many here”.

“I fear that the significance of the weekend’s incursion goes beyond the inauguration of a new Church and is a sign that the slowly emerging schism in the Anglican Communion is speeding up,” he said. “When the two largest dioceses in Australia recognise a new Anglican Church in another Anglican jurisdiction, we have a straightforward confusion of the goal of the Anglican Communion that we seek to fulfil the prayer of our Lord Jesus Christ, that they may be one.”

In their joint statement on Tuesday, the Archbishops of ACNZP, the Most Revd Philip Richardson and the Most Revd Don Tamihere, wrote: “The disrespect for the normal protocols of the Anglican Communion and the lack of courtesy shown to our Church by these boundary-crossing bishops is disturbing, and we will be making an appropriate protest about their actions.

“We are especially concerned at the boundary crossing of bishops from the Anglican Church of Australia. We value our trans-Tasman relationship with our neighbouring Church and are disappointed to find a lack of respect for the jurisdiction of our Church.”

The formation of CCAANZ and the election of Mr Behan as bishop was announced in May last year, after the general synod of the ACNZP voted to allow the blessing of same-sex marriages or civil unions (News, 11 May 2018).

Mr Behan, who has been the Vicar of St Stephen’s, Shirley, in Christchurch, for 11 years, was one of two priests who immediately announced their resignation after the vote. He will now oversee 12 parishes, while continuing in this incumbency.

An online petition begun by Canon Christopher Douglas-Huriwai, a priest in the ACNZP, requests that the Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans New Zealand remove all references to Aotearoa.

“If you are in impaired communion with [ACNZP] then you are in impaired communion with the Bishop of Aotearoa too,” he wrote. “That impairment makes any attempt at real and deep commitment to Maori as Tangata Whenua [the first people of the land] impossible.”

Forthcoming Events

21-22 February 2020
Church Times Festival of Faith and Literature
For 2020 the Bloxham festival celebrates ‘The Power of Love’. Book tickets

26 March 2020
Theology Slam Live Final
Theology Slam is back, continuing its search for the most engaging young voices on theology and the contemporary world. Find out more

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read five articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)