*** DEBUG END ***

Your answer to: am I a heretic?

01 February 2019

Write, if you have any answers to the questions listed at the end of this section, or to add to the answer given below


I am a regular churchgoer. I do not believe in Original Sin, the Virgin birth, or that Jesus died to atone for the sins of the world, or in his bodily resurrection. Am I a heretic, or are these views more generally accepted than acknowledged? [Answers, 25 January]

Your answers: Until my father died after a drawn-out and painful illness in 1971, this was my position. My nearly 40 years of being a regular churchgoer had not prepared me, and I became an atheist. I still attended church regularly for eight years. Then I was diagnosed as having depression.

I was off work for months. One day, I went for a walk and exhausted myself. Passing the church, I went in to rest. In the silence, I began to feel better. Then I heard: “O Lord of the harvest, send labourers into the field. Send some to sow and some to reap and some to clear the ground and plough and, if you will, send me.”

I was alone and gobsmacked. After much discussion with my wife, I offered to work for the local church, doing anything that would not step on other people’s toes. The Revd James B. Seaton suggested that I train as a Reader. I agreed, and came to realise that I had never been a Christian, only a churchgoer.

Before I began really to study it, I had regarded the interpretation of the Bible as interesting but not to be taken too seriously. It is, indeed, possible to find apparent contradictions in it, and difficult to believe some of its content. But it is more than a good book: it is the Christian’s guide book.

The questioner does not believe in Original Sin. Since sin is an offence against the divine law, who can avoid it? Everyone will break the divine law in some way. In earlier life, I had had difficulty with the term Original Sin because I assumed that it had something to do with human reproduction.

If you believe in a God who created the universe, a God who can do anything, what is so difficult about accepting the Virgin birth of his Son? The Bible is quite emphatic.

The Old Testament has many stories about God punishing the Children of Israel for their wrongdoing. He had to, because he is righteous, and sin must be punished. To discontinue this saga, the God of love sent Jesus (John 3.16).

The risen Jesus was not instantly recognised by Mary Magdalene, or by the two disciples on the road to Emmaus. Who would be expecting to meet someone they knew to be dead? The astonishing truth is reflected in Luke 24.37-43. Spirits have no need to eat.

What we believe is between each individual and God. Heresy is a human concept, inspired by the desire for power. Who has the right interpretation of the Bible will be revealed by God at the last judgement — the only judgement that counts.

I am now a priest, and retired. I hope that this letter helps the questioner.

(The Revd) Haydn Williams
Coalville, Leicestershire


Your question: I am in the 11th year of my dream job as organist of a Forward in Faith town-centre “mini-cathedral”, where I play a magnificent historic pipe organ. My day job comes with free accommodation, but will end soon. At that point, should I seek a new church post on a house-for-duty basis (all the rage in clerical circles, but not so fashionable for organists), or put my possessions in a lock-up garage, live in a tent, and stay where I am? Or is there another way forward?

A. G.


Address for answers and more questions: Out of the Question, Church Times, 3rd floor, Invicta House, 108-114 Golden Lane, London EC1Y 0TG.


We ask readers not to send us letters for forwarding, and those giving answers to provide full name, address, and, if possible, telephone number.

Forthcoming Events

2 November 2021
Green Church Showcase LIVE
Join us online or in Glasgow for the premiere screening of the Green Church Showcase film.

13 November 2021
Lay Ministerial Calling: Vocation and Theology
The CRC Annual Gathering, open to anyone with an interest in lay ministry.

More events

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)