*** DEBUG START ***
*** DEBUG END ***

Angela Tilby: Ways to miss the point of Christmas

by
07 December 2018

THE Church of England’s Christmas campaign publication, FollowTheStar: A journey through the 12 Days of Christmas, has come in for some criticism because of its “literalist” approach to the Christmas story (News, 5 October). Adrian Alker, who chairs Progressive Christianity Network Britain, said that “there is no serious scholar . . . who takes the birth narratives as literal fact” (Letters, 12 October).

He has a point, but also misses the point. Of course, the birth narratives can be dissected and criticised, as can any other historical accounts. But, in Christian theology, the birth narratives are more than mere texts. They are windows on to the mystery unfolded in the Creed, the incarnation of the Word for us and for our salvation. The 12 days of Christmas are days of wonder as well as celebration.

Follow the Star seeks to reach those who come to church at Christmas but otherwise have little connection with the Christian community. It tries to make the Christmas story accessible, and perhaps to trigger some lasting response in those who might take the booklet home from, say, a carol service.

So, it tries to link the Christmas story to everyday experience. For example, the arrival of Mary and Joseph in an overcrowded Bethlehem is prefaced with: “Even with thorough and detailed travel plans, things can go wrong. It is easy to miss a flight, or find a train overbooked, or transport cancelled. Nothing new, if we read the story of Christmas.”

I think this misses the point as much as the critical approach does. Both suppose, wrongly, that what is needed to make the Christmas stories accessible is explanation. But explanation on the literal or critical level fails because the stories are not as accessible as one might think. If they were, we would perhaps have stopped repeating them. For all their familiarity, the birth narratives remain deeply strange.

My guess is that those who come to church at Christmas come for that strangeness: the enchantment of candles in the darkness, hauntingly beautiful music, and a story that points beyond both the secular and the literal; a story which can neither be debunked by its critics nor reduced to assimilable fragments by an over-anxious, fervently welcoming Church. Christmas services are simply beautiful in their strangeness, and they attract people in ways that the contemporary Church does not quite understand.

The “theology” offered in Follow the Star boils down to following Jesus and doing good in the world: discipleship and do-goodery. That’s fine, up to a point; but, for many of us, it is shallow. It misses the universalism of the Christmas story. It also misses the heart’s yearning for the otherness of the divine, the hush before the first notes of the choir, for the seeds of contemplation.

Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Letters to the editor

Letters for publication should be sent to letters@churchtimes.co.uk.

Letters should be exclusive to the Church Times, and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear below your letter unless requested otherwise.

Forthcoming Events

“Awake and Hearken”: Listening for the Advent voice

21 November 2026

An Advent retreat with Rebecca Stephens, Richard Carter, Alison Jack and Paula Gooder - online only.

tickets available now

Festival of Faith and Literature 2027: “The Power of Story”

Friday 26 February - Sunday 28 February 2027

The Festival of Faith and Literature returns to Winchester in February 2027. The programme is filled with engaging speakers, including Sir Ben Okri, Pippa White, Malcolm Guite, Sir Anthony Seldon and Francis Spufford.

tickets available now

 

Visit our Events page for upcoming and past events

 

 

 

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times

To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

New to us? Non-subscribers can read up to four free articles a month. Simply sign up for a free account to receive the Church Times newsletter, plus exclusive offers and events, straight to your inbox. As a thank you for joining us, we are also currently offering a £5 discount for the Church House Bookshop online (valid for one order of £30 or more). See your welcome email for details.