Ready-made target

05 January 2018

BBC/Laurence Cendrowicz

Stylish: in The Miniaturist (BBC1), Nella (right), played by Anya Taylor-Joy, attends a Bible-reading in her new household in Amsterdam

Stylish: in The Miniaturist (BBC1), Nella (right), played by Anya Taylor-Joy, attends a Bible-reading in her new household in Amsterdam

CHRISTIANITY having not a little to do with the very existence of the festival, it is hardly unreasonable to enquire how the Church was por­­trayed in this year’s Christmas TV. A royalty ought to be paid to Churches Together by the Writers’ Guild for furnishing them with a ready-made source of malevolence and repression.

If your drama needs a dark force against which your hero(ine) can ap­­pear by contrast to be the em­­bodiment of grace and enlighten­ment, then Christian churches — and, in particular, their ministers — will do very nicely, saving authors the bother of proper research and ima­ginative engagement with the standards and expectations of times and places other than our own.

The Miniaturist (BBC1, 26 and 27 December) was an excellent and stylish example of this trend. The dark secret blighting the 1686 Am­sterdam household that the beautiful Nella enters as a young bride is that her husband is (actively) homosexual. Of course, the Church seeks to root out and punish all those who thus overstep the boundaries of righteousness; Nella and his family are beacons of tolerance and under­standing. If you are willing to over­look all this anachronistic hokum, however, it is a terrific drama.

The doll’s-house furniture and fit­­tings made by the Miniaturist herself were, in particular, creations of quite extraordinary delight.

Possibly we might not be meant to take the Christian minister as por­trayed in The League of Gentlemen (BBC2, 18, 19, 20 December) quite so seriously. Nearly 20 years after the original series depicting the un­­paralleled horrors of life in Royston Vasey, the team return to cross-dress their way through an embodiment of every nightmare you ever suffered, and provide you with new ones.

The Vicar, Bernice Woodall, is now the Mayor, and an extra frisson is milked by the contrast between her foul language and the expectations of gentle goodness suggested by her clerical collar. But I suspect that, amid the gleeful overstepping of every bound­ary of acceptable good taste, she is not supposed to represent a su­­s­tained critique of the behaviour of the average C of E cleric.

Oddly, if a serious purpose is to be disinterred from the debris, it is a savage blast against the folly of Brexit, the maniacal mantra of “a local shop for local people” now having taken on a sinister resonance unimagined by the original series.

There were less critical views of our faith to be enjoyed — as long as you went abroad. Alinka Echeverria’s three-part series The Art That Made Mexico: Paradise, power and prayers (BBC4, 18 December) concluded by exploring the essential part played by religion and faith — as much today as in the past.

The Conquistadores, attempting to save the souls of their captive people as well as steal their gold, did every­thing in their power to extirpate every trace of the pagan beliefs: but, over time, a more generous, syn­cretistic fusion has produced a rapprochement whereby both art and ritual combine key characteristics of both faith sy­­s­tems.

100 Best Christian Books

How many have you read?

Visit the 100 Best Christian Books website to see which books made our list, read the judges' notes and add your own comments.

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

The Church Times Podcast

Interviews and news analysis from the Church Times team. Listen to this week’s episode online

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read twelve articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)