The art of remembering

by
26 January 2018

Caroline Levisse marks Holocaust Memorial Day with a look at some remarkable drawings

© Thomas Fritta-Haas, on long-term loan to the Jewish Museum, Berlin/Jens Ziehe

A Transport Leaves the Ghetto by Bedrich Fritta 1942/43, ink, pen and brush, wash

A Transport Leaves the Ghetto by Bedrich Fritta 1942/43, ink, pen and brush, wash

SINCE 2000, Holocaust Memorial Day has been com­­memorated on 27 January, the anniversary of the liberation of the largest death camp, Auschwitz-Birkenau. It is a day to remember the victims of the Holo­caust and later genocides, and also to honour those who stood — and are standing — against such mas­­sacres.

With the passing of time, the memory of this event might fade, but each act of remembrance keeps the memory alive. We can listen to the survivors’ stories, read their books, and visit memorials, but there is a further group of objects that helps us to get closer to the victims.

Between 1939 and 1945, thou­sands of drawings and other works of art were created by pri­soners of ghettos and con­­centration camps. These fragile works are moving and, at times, haunt­ing. They are a testa­ment to people’s re­­sili­ence, courage, and continued hope in the face of evil. I came upon them when I taught about the art and artists of the Second World War. I was deeply moved, and so were my students, who showed great interest. Our responses to the drawings left me with the desire to tell more people about them and perpetuate their witness.

 

©Yad Vashem Art Museum, JerusalemBowl of Hot Soup by Halina Olomucki, 1945, pencil on paper; from the collection of the Yad Vashem Art Museum, Jerusalem (gift of the artist)

MOST of the works were done with pencil on paper. These materials were not only the easiest to find, but also the easiest to hide, or smuggle out of the ghetto or concentration camp. In Stuffhof con­­­­centration camp, in Germany, the Jewish artist Esther Lurie (1913-98) was able to draw portraits of fellow prisoners, thanks to a pencil that she obtained from one of the secretaries. She drew on wrapping paper from packages of cotton wool collected for her by a Jewish doctor at the infirm­­ary.

Many others used art supplies that they found through their work assignments as illustrators, painters, or decorators. A Polish Jew, Halina Olomucki (1919-2007), was 18 years old when she was deported to the Warsaw ghetto. In May 1943, she was transported to Majdanek con­­cen­tra­tion camp and, immed­iately after­wards, to Auschwitz-Birkenau.

There, she was assigned to paint signs and make decorations for the barracks. While in Auschwitz, she also created more than 200 drawings in secret, and hid them between the wooden planks of her barracks.

After the war, she managed to find clandestine drawings that she had made while in the Warsaw ghetto and that she had given to a Polish friend living on the other side of the ghetto wall. She retrieved only a fraction of the drawings that she had made in Auschwitz.

 

IN THE ghetto of Theresienstadt, north of Prague, the artists Leo Haas (1901-83), Bedrich Fritta (1906-44), Ferdinand Bloch (1898-1944), and Otto Ungar (1901-45) worked in the Technical Depart­ment. Before the war, they had been painters and graphic designers, and now had to use their artistic skills to produce illustra­­tions for Nazi propa­ganda. The pictures that they were forced to create were supposed to reinforce the image of the ghetto as a self-governed model settlement, where the Jews did indeed live in is­ola­tion, but in ac­­­ceptable con­­ditions.

The department quickly became a centre for unofficial work. All four used the department’s materials secretly to realise hundreds of draw­­ings that depicted daily life in the ghetto. These clandestine draw­­ings led ultimately to their arrest in 1944. Haas, Fritta, Bloch, and Ungar were accused of creating “atrocity propa­ganda” (Greuel­propa­ganda), and of attempting to smuggle it out of the ghetto.

They were subsequently incar­cerated and tortured in the ghetto’s prison, where Bloch died in October 1944. The others were deported to Auschwitz. Fritta died shortly after his arrival; Ungar experienced the liberation of the camp, only to die in 1945 owing to his weakened state. Of the four, only Haas survived. He was later able to retrieve some of the drawings: he found them where they had been carefully hidden, plastered in the walls of the Theresienstadt ghetto.

There was not always someone left to retrieve the drawings. In 1947, drawings were found in Auschwitz, hidden in a bottle, which was itself concealed beneath the foundations of a barrack. This series of sketches, known as “The Sketchbook from Au­­­schwitz”, depicts, in troubling detail, the murder of Jews in the extermina­tion camp of Birkenau. They are some of the very few first-hand visual records of what hap­­pened in this death camp. Their value as docu­ments is thus con­­siderable; in a few instances, draw­ings were used in trials as prosecu­tion exhibits.

Auschwitz-Birkenau MuseumA page from the Sketchbook from Auschwitz by an unknown artist, done in Auschwitz, c.1943, pencil on paper

 

CONSIDERING the fragility of these works, and that they were often lost, destroyed, or con­­fiscated, the number of drawings that have survived is remarkable. That so many were created, despite the danger and difficulties, shows how strongly the prisoners were mo­­tivated. An art historian and curator at Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum, Agnieszka Sieradzka, says of the “Auschwitz Sketchbook”: “You can clearly see that the author was deter­­mined to present the largest number of details. Badges of functionary pri­soners, number plates of the trucks, train cars on the ramp, as well as block numbers are carefully de­­picted. The author of the sketchbook hoped that someone would find his work so that it would become a witness to ex­­termination” (quote in “Witness to Extermination” by Alex Macbeth, in Der Spiegel, 2012).

Many of the artists who survived incarceration have spoken of the strong and irrepressible need that these drawings fulfilled: they were part of an effort to become visible, and to tell the world what was truly happening. Olomucki re­­mem­­bered: “While I was in Auschwitz-Bir­kenau, someone told me, ‘If you live to leave this hell, make your draw­ings and tell the world about us. We want to remain among the living, at least on paper’” (quoted in Spiritual Resis­tance: Art from concentration camps, 1940-1945, by M. Novitch, L. Dawidowicz, and T. L. Freudenheim, 1981).

Olomucki’s drawings, created in the Warsaw ghetto before she was deported to Auschwitz, as well as those made by Haas and Fritta in the Theresienstadt ghetto, were a de­­liberate effort to document daily life under Nazi persecution. They depicted, among other things, the com­ing and going of transports bring­­ing in new prisoners or sending them on to concentration and exter­mination camps; roll-calls; exe­­cutions; forced labour; distribu­tion of food; cramped sleeping-quarters; and theatre per­form­­ances on make­­shift stages. In this way, they com­­plement other initiatives, such as the creation of secret arch­ives.

This effort at documentation was a way to regain control over the telling of history rather than disap­­pear into the Nazi propaganda ma­­chine. Pris­oners were aware that their com­mun­ity was threatened with total an­­nihila­tion. Together with teach­­­­­­­ing children and holding reli­­gious cere­monies, or gathering in prayer groups, these clan­des­tine activ­­­­­ities were a form of “spirit­ual re­­­sistance”.

The drawings were a way to affirm one’s existence, both as an individual and a member of a com­munity. De­­hu­­manisation was central to the Nazis’ strategy of exter­­­mina­­tion. The functioning of con­­­centra­­tion and extermination camps was aimed at de­­priving pris­oners of any sense of in­­dividuality. A former in­­mate quoted by Raul Hilberg in The Destruction of the European Jews (Yale, 1961, 2003), recounted that, in Auschwitz, only “the anonymous, the faceless ones, survived.”

This makes the number of clan­­des­tine portraits created of the artist’s fellow inmates particularly tel­­­­ling. Portraiture is the most repre­sented genre in the graphic works produced by prisoners during the Holocaust.

Auschwitz-Birkenau MuseumPortrait of a Young Woman by Zofia Stepién, done in Auschwitz in 1944, pencil on paper

 

THE Polish artist Franciszek Jazwiecki (1900-46) was a po­­­litical prisoner in Auschwitz. Between 1943 and 1945, he made 114 portraits of other pris­­oners, who are represented in their striped uni­­forms; exhaustion and despair can often be read on their faces.

Sometimes, the portraits were com­­missioned by the other inmates, and artists could barter them for food. This is what the Polish Jewish artist Zofia Stepién-Bator (b. 1920) did while in Auschwitz. She later ex­­plained that she had intentionally made everyone look better than they actually did. She represented the sitters with normal clothes, instead of the prisoner’s outfit; gave them good hairdos, and fuller cheeks.

With these portraits, the artists and her sitters seemed to have refused to let what was happening to them define who they were. The portraits restored a sense of self.

If Jazwiecki and Stepién-Bator both insisted, in their portraits, on the dignity and humanity of their fellow inmates, these works also served a crucial purpose for the artists themselves. Being able to barter food for her drawings in­­­creased Stepién-Bator’s chances of sur­­vival.

Auschwitz-Birkenau MuseumPortrait of an Unknown Prisoner by Franciszek Jazwiecki, done in Auschwitz in 1942, pencil on paper

Jazwiecki observed: “For a mo­­ment of happiness, or actually for­get­ting . . . I have been making pencil portraits in the camp. The portraits were made on the sly, in secret, and were a moment of for­­getting for me. They took me to a different world — the world of art. I simply disregarded the fact that draw­­ing was punishable by death; I did that not because of courage. I just didn’t pay any attention to the danger; it was so attractive to be and work in this world of mine” (quoted by M. Bohm-Duchen in Art and the Second World War, Princeton, 2013). The act of creation became a momentary escape.

 

IF SOME of the drawings are very factual in their depictions of scenes from ghettos and camps, others are clearly more concerned with artistic aspects. When Bedrich Fritta repre­­sented a group of people leaving the ghetto under the sur­­veillance of a soldier, he skilfully tilted the lines of the buildings and trees to emphasise the movement, and reinforce the way in which the prisoners’ bodies are bowed down by the heavy burden that they carry.

Such attention to aesthetic effects reminds us that these drawings are not simply documents, but works of art. Like acts of solidarity, the cre­ation of art conveys hope for human­­ity. Even when totally sur­rounded by death and alienation, human beings were driven to do good and beautiful things.

Dr Caroline Levisse teaches art history at the Workers’ Educational Association, and is a Visiting Re­­search Fellow at the Centre for Arts and the Sacred at King’s College, London.

Christmas Subscription Offer

Treat friends and family to a gift subscription this year.

We’ll send a Christmas card announcing your gift and your choice of free book:
After Prayer by Malcolm Guite or
Revenge of the Flower Arrangers 
by Dave Walker

Choose a gift subscription

Forthcoming Events

21-22 February 2020
Church Times Festival of Faith and Literature
For 2020 the Bloxham festival celebrates ‘The Power of Love’. Book tickets

26 March 2020
Theology Slam Live Final
Theology Slam is back, continuing its search for the most engaging young voices on theology and the contemporary world. Find out more

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read five articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)