Stating his case

19 January 2018

PA

Tim Farron told Premier Christian Radio that he regretted saying, during last year’s General Election campaign, that homosexuality was not a sin

Tim Farron told Premier Christian Radio that he regretted saying, during last year’s General Election campaign, that homosexuality was not a sin

“WE ARE talking different languages. . . . If you’re a Christian, you’ve got a very clear idea of what sin is. . . But, if you’re not a Christian, it is different.”

Tim Farron’s interview for the Break­­­fast strand on Premier Christian Radio (Wednesday of last week) is worth listening to in full. The take-home headline was that he regretted saying during the 2017 General Election campaign that homosexual sex was not a sin (News, 28 April 2017); but the full 15-minute exchange is instructive for what it tells us about the near-impossibility of doing religion in British politics.

Mr Farron said that he was a “counter-cultural” Christian: he is an Evangelical of the Left, socially con­servative, and politically liberal. One can sympathise with his frustra­tion, but what many people will find objectionable is his appropriation of the Christian “language” in the ser­vice of one particular moral stance. At no point was it suggested that other Christians might hold other views regarding homo­sexuality, or, in­­­deed, the nature of sin itself. Mr Farron’s lament over the impoverish­ment of religious discourse in the public sphere might be reasonable, but it is this sort of reductionism that exacerbates the problem.

We should not be too harsh: stick a microphone in front of anybody with a cause, and they are liable to over­play their hand. A textbook case was the performance of the psychother­apist Steve Pope on the World Service’s Newshour Extra (Friday). The topic was gaming addiction, and the panel included academics and industry bigwigs. But Mr Pope was the authentic voice of the counsellor who had seen the addiction at the sharp end; we heard from one of his patients, a promising young foot­baller, Jack, who had thrown it all away in his obsession for the video game Call of Duty. Benders lasting three days, peeing into plastic bottles — it is because of young men like Jack that the World Health Organ­ization has designated gaming addic­tion as a distinct mental-health con­dition.

It was when Mr Pope started telling us that it is a greater problem even than gambling, alcohol, and drugs that he began to lose us. There is a fair amount of research out there, conducted by bodies such as the Oxford Internet Unit, which pours cooling water on to these incendiary claims. Then a representative from the gaming industry told us that, in fact, gaming was excellent in devel­oping hand-eye co-ordination, cog­nitive skills, and even social con­fidence.

Dr Andrew Przybylski, of Oxford University, said that our instinctive bias in favour of real games — in the open air, with real people — over digital games has no rational basis, and is unsupported by current re­­search . . . at which point this listener started feeling queasy. OK, so today’s game-obsessed youth might not all be micturating into unconventional ves­sels or conducting drive-by shoot­ings, but surely fresh air is better than the imagined smell of some body-strewn virtual battleground.

100 Best Christian Books

How many have you read?

Visit the 100 Best Christian Books website to see which books made our list, read the judges' notes and add your own comments.

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

The Church Times Podcast

Interviews and news analysis from the Church Times team. Listen to this week’s episode online

Forthcoming Events

5-6 May 2018

Church Times Festival of Poetry
With Sarum College, Salisbury. More details coming soon - register your interest here

Subscribe now to get full access

To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read up to twelve articles for free. (You will need to register.)