*** DEBUG END ***

From a transient to a permanent presence

07 July 2017

Short-term ministry schemes are valuable — but they cannot replace long-term commitment to a parish, says Claire Jones

“YOU can’t leave now: we’ve only just got used to you.” Dorothy’s smile had dropped quickly from her face. Her words struck a chord, because it was the second time I’d heard them in as many days.

As the final weeks of our nine-month placement as ministry assist­­ants approached, my col­­leagues and I knew that there would be plenty of goodbyes. The small congregation at a monthly euchar­ist, held in the tower blocks in our parish, was just the next farewell in the diary.

But the note of accusation in Do­­rothy’s voice caught me off guard, just as it had when our next-door neighbour had called out exactly the same words the previous day.

The Church of England Ministry Experience Scheme (CEMES), which now has placements in 21 dioceses, seeks to give young adults the chance to explore their vocation, while getting their hands dirty in parish life. Aimed at those coming out of study or happy to leave full-time employment, it offers a dif­­ferent way of life, built on pract­ical service, worship, and study. A dio­cesan director of ordinands has a direct link with the scheme, creating a clear pathway through the dio­cesan discernment process.

Taking part in such a scheme can provide further opportunities for learning and growth: some, as I did, move to an unfamiliar part of the country, and have a chance to walk and work alongside experienced priests in a very different trad­­ition to their own. I will carry with me into ministry all that I have dis­covered on placement in Sunder­land about identity, humility, service, and, ultimately, God.

For participants, the set-up is no doubt well designed; CEMES is credited with contributing to the rise in numbers of ordinands — of whom I will be one — who will begin training in September (News, 16 June).


FROM Dorothy’s perspective, though, things look a little dif­­ferent. In an area where very few new faces come or go, where gen­erations live on the same street, and neighbours tend to know one another’s every move, the arrival of three newcomers in the empty vicarage caused some­thing of a disturbance. Young adults moving from different parts of the country to come to this estate to live, work, and worship together were sure to stick out in every way.

Over nine months, we have held community activity events (Com­ment, 21 April), set up an after-school club, and met parishioners coming for baptisms, banns, and burials. We have worked hard to earn the trust of those whom we have lived and served alongside, strange as they, no doubt, still think we are. Of course, our presence took some getting used to. All the while, a cloud of transience hovered over the relationships that we built.

It is, perhaps, of little surprise that the church on this estate, with declining congregation numbers and the rough reputation of the area, is in a permanent interregnum and is looked after by the priests of neighbouring parishes. During our time here, we have been encouraged by the evidence that living day by day as a Christian presence in this community can bring some small change.

But for real transformation to occur, that presence needs to be long-­term. It is only through rela­tion­­ships sustained over many years that children who are starting to grasp the love of God will go on to see it change the apparently inevit­able course of their lives. It is only by a consistent invitation that fam­ilies who are beginning to see the church as a place of welcome rather than hostility will become confident that God’s welcome really extends to them.

A nine-month placement is not nearly long enough to make a dent in the challenges, both social and spiritual, faced by many who live in a deprived parish such as this.


MANY of the concerns rightly directed towards those who embark on short-term mission projects abroad could also be asked of similar, relatively short-term experi­­ences in this country. We must examine our attitudes to com­­­munities where poverty is prevalent and ask whether they are equal partners in outreach or people that we “do mission to” for only as long as it serves our purposes.

The sustainability of new in­­itiatives is an important con­­side­ra­tion, as is the long-term im­pact on the existing worshipping com­­­mun­ity. The conclusions are the same, whether at home or abroad: short-term placements are good for the community only where they con­­­­tribute to a committed, long-term investment in an area.

So then, Dorothy’s words set out a two-fold challenge. First, for the Church of England, that it must not view short-term placements such as CEMES, which primarily benefit the participants rather than the com­­munities where they are based, as a replacement for the ongoing, un­­­glamorous work of permanent pre­­­sence in a community.

And second, for the new crop of young ordinands like me: it will not be long before we have real choices to make about where to begin and live out our ministry. Having spent a few months seeing the need for ministers to put down roots in deprived parishes, we should be listening, more attentively than any­­one, for God’s call to step forward and stay put.


Claire Jones worked in three par­ishes in Sunderland as part of the Church of England’s Ministry Experience Scheme in the north-east.


Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Letters to the editor

Letters for publication should be sent to letters@churchtimes.co.uk.

Letters should be exclusive to the Church Times, and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear below your letter unless requested otherwise.

Forthcoming Events

Green Church Awards

Closing date: 30 June 2024

Read more details about the awards


Festival of Preaching

15-17 September 2024

The festival moves to Cambridge along with a sparkling selection of expert speakers

tickets available



Festival of Faith and Literature

28 February - 2 March 2025

The festival programme is soon to be announced sign up to our newsletter to stay informed about all festival news.

Festival website


ViSIt our Events page for upcoming and past events 

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times


To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)