Stainer’s resurrection cantata

05 May 2017

Roderic Dunnett on The Daughter of Jairus


Christ Resurrects the Daughter of Jairus by Johann Friedrich Overbeck

Christ Resurrects the Daughter of Jairus by Johann Friedrich Overbeck

SIR JOHN STAINER is remembered primarily for one work: his Passion “Meditation”, The Crucifixion. Yet he was one of the outstanding musi­cians of the 19th century. He com­posed some 30 anthems, so that although his “I saw the Lord” has been widely recorded, only one collection of some eight anthems (plus an Evening Service) exists, recorded by Benjamin Nich­olas and the first-rate choir of Tewkesbury Abbey (Priory PRCD 833).

Yet there exists a smattering of larger works: an oratorio, Gideon, composed in 1865 for his doctorate; a cantata, St. Mary Mag­dalen, for the 1883 Gloucester Three Choirs; and the shamefully neglected The Daughter of Jairus (1878), also for the Three Choirs, which has now been recovered from oblivion at Welshpool Town Hall, Powys, by the captivating Guilsfield Singers.

This is not the first revival since the Leeds Festival performance in 1910: an enlarged St Bartholomew’s Polyphony Choir, redubbed the Stainer Centenary Chorus, revived it with full orchestra at St Michael and All Angels, Croydon, in 2001, where it was also recorded.

We owe this mid-Wales initiative, however, to the Guilsfield choir’s enterprising music director, Gerry Howe, who oversaw the necessary editing of (mainly) the non-string parts from the original 1878 score, held along with the Stainer archive by Durham University. Jeremy Dibble, at Dur­ham, is Stainer’s bio­grapher (Boydell & Brewer).

And a staggeringly impressive cantata Howe’s conducting revealed Jairus to be. He characterises it, with­out hyperbole, as “a neglected little masterpiece of English Church Music”; but it is, in fact, as this up­­lifting performance revealed, a weighty and striking setting of the biblical narrative, with some well-imagined supplementing of the story. The chorus contributed to this uplift: choir passages were ro­bust and engaging, sung with complete assurance and a feel for the idiom.

The Overture is substantial, and extended, anticipating several points in the work: quite an achievement in itself. After a jaunty first chorus, “In that day shall the Lord of Hosts”, in which upper voices yield to a more reflective passage for lower parts, the work moves straight to the soprano narration, as Jesus is ap­­proached by the deeply distressed father (”My little daughter . . .”), sung with feel­ing by the bass Michael Birchwood.


The crowd interferes (rather as at the anointing at Bethany), but the soprano assures him: “Fear not, and she shall be made whole.” The sop­rano Sarah Garrett’s contribution to the narrative was enchanting. Clearly the child’s recovery will be dependent on the belief of the fa­ther.

A lovely tenor solo follows, “My hope is in the Everlasting”, beauti­fully crafted, and alluringly sung by Christopher Barnes. But the female chorus is already lamenting the child’s passing (”Sweet, tender flower”) in gently rhymed half-lines and, perhaps surprisingly, not un­­duly cloying: “Sleep, gentle child, pure, undefiled: weeping to dust we yield thee.” What might a few de­c­ades ago have seemed unduly senti­mental does not so now: one is con­tent to let the Victorian idiom stand, just as one makes similar al­­lowances for, say, Elgar’s Carac­tacus.

While the women mourn, the men, led first by the tenors, are sneer­ing and cynical: “This man professeth to have knowledge of God, let us see if his words be true.” But it is to the upper voices that the miracle is allotted: “And he entered in where the damsel was lying, and took her hand . . . and her spirit came again, and she arose and walked.” In 1878, it is likely that Stainer had in mind his own loss, in 1874, of his infant son, “a sweet curly headed boy”, in whose memory his touching anthem “They have taken away my Lord” was com­posed.

The orchestral harmonies here could almost be early Wagner. There follows the trumpeting chorus “Awake, thou that sleepest”, in lively triple time, and the spurring to pur­ity and innocence: “Be dead unto sin. . . Let not sin reign in your mortal body,” encompassing a neat fugato passage.

The soprano and tenor duet “Love Divine, all loves excelling”, lauding Christian perfection, is the most exquisite piece of music here, setting with utter freshness the celebrated hymn of Charles Wesley: operatic in character, its word-painting eclipses the better-known hymn tune that Stainer composed for those words.

It opens the way to a resplendent Finale, “To him who left his throne on high”, in which Stainer builds a superbly vital double fugue; there are echoes of Handel here, but also of Bach’s craftsmanship: Stainer was perhaps the supreme late-19th-century executant of Bach’s organ music. The cantata’s conclusion has, dare one venture it, all the flair of the “Hallelujah Chorus’.

So, this was a huge success, en­­riched by the well-prepared Maldwyn Strings (and some exciting additional wind and brass): full of spirit and vitality, as well as tenderness, from the choir, and ingenuity from the conductor and soloists. Startlingly rewarding, The Daughter of Jairus deserves to be championed by more than a handful of England’s more articulate choral societies.

A performance of the work from the Nieuwe Kerk, Amsterdam, is on The St Bartholomew’s choir’s English CD recording is £7.50 (including p&p) from Reprinted or secondhand vocal scores are readily available online.

100 Best Christian Books

How many have you read?

Visit the 100 Best Christian Books website to see which books made our list, read the judges' notes and add your own comments.

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

The Church Times Podcast

Interviews and news analysis from the Church Times team. Listen to this week’s episode online

Forthcoming Events

5-6 May 2018
Church Times Festival of Poetry
With Sarum College, Salisbury.
Speakers include: Rachel Mann, Mark Oakley and Michael Symmons Roberts, among others.
Find out more and book tickets

Subscribe now to get full access

To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read up to twelve articles for free. (You will need to register.)