*** DEBUG END ***

Learning to discern

28 April 2017

In the second article of a new series on hearing voices, Chris Cook looks at the implications of this phenomenon for Christian spirituality


Dark night of the soul: Salvador Dali’s Christ of St John of the Cross

Dark night of the soul: Salvador Dali’s Christ of St John of the Cross

EXPERIENCES of hearing God’s voice are very diverse. For some people, it happens once in a lifetime; for others, it is a daily occurrence. Some hear God “out loud”; others describe it as being as though “God put a thought into my mind.” Yet others have no particular experience of “hearing a voice”, but, rather, encounter God in scripture, nature, and other people.

Research by Tanya Luhrmann, in the United States and elsewhere, and by Simon Dein and Roland Littlewood, in the UK, has shown that Christians hear God when pray­ing more commonly than might have been supposed.

In a study by Dein and Little­wood in a Pentecostal church in north-east London, 25 out of 40 Christians who completed question­naires indicated that they heard God’s voice in answer to their prayers. The voice was clearly dis­tin­guished from their own thoughts, and usually focused on immediate and practical issues. Fifteen respondents had heard the voice speaking aloud, although this was usually a once in a lifetime experi­ence.

As Luhrmann indicates in her book When God Talks Back, spir­itual practices commonly encoun­tered in both Evangelical and Cath­olic circles can lead to a state of absorption in prayer within which there is an intense inner focus. If, as is often the case, this is associated with an expectation that God will speak, then, sometimes, sensory overrides occur.

Sensory overrides are experiences in which perception overrides the actual sensory stimuli that the brain is processing. When this occurs in prayer, then God — who is not material — is experienced in a sensory way.

Luhrmann leaves open the ques­tion of the theological interpretation of such experiences, but she notes that, within the churches that she studied, there is an awareness of the need for discernment. It should not automatically be assumed that the voice is from God. For example, is it the kind of thing that God might reasonably be expected to say? If the voice contradicted scripture, it should not be believed. And the question should always be asked: might this simply have been my own thought?

Not everyone is equally able to enter the state of absorption which seems to facilitate sensory overrides. It seems likely that different prayer practices are more likely to generate sensory overrides than others. Few people can have spent as much time in prayer as Thomas Merton, and yet there is no indication that he ever heard a voice in his prayers.

Moreover, Christian spirituality has traditionally been wary of placing too much weight on such experi­ences. St John of the Cross, for ex­­ample, warned that they leave people open to deception, pride, and a diminishment of faith.


GOD’s voice is not heard only dur­ing states of intense prayer, and is sometimes completely unexpected. Mother Teresa first experienced the voice that called her to her work with the poor when she was on a train journey to Darjeeling.

Mary Neal, an orthopaedic sur­geon, in her book To Heaven and Back, describes her multi-sensory, near-death experience during a kayak accident. Susan Atkins, serv­ing a life sentence in prison for her part in the Manson murders, writes in her autobiography of hearing the voice of Jesus in her prison cell. Hugh Montefiore, later Bishop of Kingston, heard Jesus speak to him when sitting alone, a dejected teen­ager, in his study at school.

We now know that voices are heard by many ordinary people, religious or not. Voices have been traditionally associated with serious mental illness, however, and the hallu­cinations and delusions experi­enced by people with psychosis frequently include spiritual and religious content. Typically, this is not the positive kind of experience reported by Luhrmann, or by Dein and Littlewood.

While the voices heard may be understood to have a divine origin, they may also be experienced as demonic, and may be deeply distressing.

Negative voices of this kind are associated with significant stigma. Research suggests that Christians have variable experiences of support from their church communities. Potentially, at least, churches can provide positive networks of support which are deeply valued by those undergoing experiences of this kind. Prayer can also provide an important coping resource.


BECAUSE voices span such a wide spectrum — from heavenly to hellish — there has been much debate about how to distinguish between the good and the bad. One approach, which I do not favour, is to offer a guide to dif­feren­tial dia­gnosis: to distinguish the signs of voi­ces that are associ­ated with mental illness from those that are “true” spiritual experiences.

There are problems with this model, not least that it seems to imply that God does not talk to people who are mentally ill, only to those who are well. This is really just a mirror image of the approach that dismisses all religious or spiritual experience as an indica­tion of mental illness. Surely, the reality is much more complicated than this, and why should God not have more to say to those who are undergoing deep emotional turmoil?


THE approach taken by St John of the Cross would seem to have much to commend it. Voices, whether ap­­pearing to be from God or else­where, should not be ac­­cepted uncritically, and should not be sensationalised. Criteria for discernment are needed. Some­times, however, it would seem that God really does talk back.


Professor Cook is a co-investigator on the Wellcome-funded project Hearing the Voice, at Durham University: http://hearingthevoice.org.

He is keen to hear from readers who are willing to share their own experiences of hearing spiritually significant voices. He can be contacted at c.c.h.cook@durham.ac.uk.


Correction: In last week’s article, the quotation was incorrectly attributed to John Woolman. It was that of George Fox.

Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Forthcoming Events

Green Church Awards

Closing date: 30 June 2024

Read more details about the awards


Festival of Preaching

15-17 September 2024

The festival moves to Cambridge along with a sparkling selection of expert speakers

tickets available



Festival of Faith and Literature

28 February - 2 March 2025

The festival programme is soon to be announced sign up to our newsletter to stay informed about all festival news.

Festival website


ViSIt our Events page for upcoming and past events 

Welcome to the Church Times


To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)