Essex parishes vote against their bishops

23 June 2017

JOHN SALMON/CREATIVE COMMONS

St Elisabeth’s, Becontree: its congregation voted unanimously

St Elisabeth’s, Becontree: its congregation voted unanimously

THE diocese of Chelmsford “regrets” the decision taken by the vicars of two churches in Essex to declare publicly no confidence in the “unbiblical” leadership of the Bishop, the Rt Revd Stephen Cottrell — and that of the Archbishops of Canterbury and York — over what they call sexuality, a spokesman has said.

The Vicar of St Elisabeth’s, Becon­tree, the Revd Steven Hanna, and the Vicar of St George’s, Dagenham, the Revd Simon Smallwood, wrote in an open letter last week that motions of no confidence had been passed “unan­­imously” by St Elisabeth’s, and with one vote against and one ab­­stention at St George’s, at their annual church meetings, in April. The Area Bishop of Barking, the Rt Revd Peter Hill, was also included in the no-confidence motion.

It came after Bishop Cottrell told his diocesan synod in March that there was “no reason why prayers of thanksgiving for these relationships — perhaps a eucharist — cannot be offered” to same-sex couples soon. His proposals would put into practice the “radical inclusion” of LGBT Chris­­tians called for by the Arch­bishops (News, 17 February, 17 March). Mr Hanna later wrote to Bishop Cottrell to say that his church would not attend a deanery event on discipleship (News, 24 March).

But a spokesman for the diocese responded on Wednesday that the letter was “premature” and possibly damaging. “The Archbishops and the Bishop have not authorised any change to C of E doctrine or practice regarding marriage but they are encour­aging open discussions be­­tween Christians in a desire for the Church to be inclusive,” he said. “We, therefore, believe the decision of these churches to be premature at the very least and at worst damaging to the good relationships that we enjoy across a diversity of opinions.”“No confidence”: the Revd Steven Hanna has criticised “unbiblical” leadership

The letter, published on the blog Anglican Mainstream, read: “Given the current turmoil in the Church of England, especially the un­­biblical lea­der­­ship offered by Arch­bishops Wel­by and Sentamu in their joint letter after the February General Synod and the lack of biblical leader­ship in our own diocese of Chelm­s­ford, parti­cular­ly the failure to teach sound doctrine and the refusal to re­­fute, publicly, false teaching and prac­tice, each congregation was asked to con­sider the current leadership in light of the biblical requirement for bishops.”

The motion proposed by St George’s also resolved to reject visit­ing preachers who did not make a commitment to its theological posi­tion statement on sexuality, and no longer to consider as Anglicans clerics who had “walked away” from ortho­dox teachings on marriage. It de­­scribed the synodical discus­sions and papers on sexuality as a “crisis”.

Mr Hanna said on Wednesday that he had since received a response from Lambeth Palace, but that it was “not encouraging” because it referred only to the legalising of same-sex marriage in the UK. “It failed to comment on what is happening now,” he said. “It was odd: the Archbishops were trying to give the impression that they were working hard to maintain the line of orthodoxy when evidently that is not the case.”

A spokesperson confirmed that Lambeth Palace had responded to the letter but declined to comment on private correspondence.

In a letter to the Church Times this week, however, the former Second Church Estates Commissioner Sir Tony Baldry re­­mind­ed Mr Hanna and Mr Small­wood that “the Church of England is an episcopal Church, in which clergy take an oath of canon­ical obedience to their diocesan bishop.”

The clerics should also consider that the General Synod was respons­ible for matters of wor­ship and doc­­­­­­trine, Sir Tony wrote, and that it was the clergy who had voted against the report on sexuality from the Bishops, who were bring­ing a teach­ing docu­ment to the next sessions.

Letters

Forthcoming Events

9 October
The Parish: Has it Had its Day?

Join us for a Moral Maze-style debate at St Mellitus College, London. Tickets £10 (£5 for students/ordinands). Read more and book tickets

The Church Times Podcast

The Church Times Podcast, hosted by Tim Wyatt and Ed Thornton, features a mixture of interviews and news analysis. Listen online

Subscribe now to get full access

To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read seven articles each month for free.