New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
UK >

Landmark urban growth report was branded as 'Marxist analysis'

Tim Wyatt

by Tim Wyatt

Posted: 08 Jan 2016 @ 12:06


Click to enlarge

Back then: the then Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Robert Runcie, talking to the then Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher, in 1983

Credit: PA

Back then: the then Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Robert Runcie, talking to the then Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher, in 1983

THE landmark Faith in the City report was condemned as endorsing a “Marxist analysis” of society by one of Margaret Thatcher’s key advisers, newly released government papers have shown.

Brian Griffiths, who was head of the Number 10 Policy Unit in the mid-1980s, criticised the report for blaming societal injustice and government policy for poverty in the inner-cities, rather than encouraging the poor to take personal responsibility for their predicament.

Faith in the City, a nearly 400-page examination of life and religion in poor inner-city regions, was commissioned by the then Archbishop of Canterbury, Robert Runcie. Before it was released, in December 1985, the contents were leaked to the press and described by an unnamed Cabinet minister as “pure Marxist theology”.

Now, Cabinet Office archives released in the New Year show that many of those close to Mrs Thatcher agreed. Mr Griffiths wrote a summary of Faith in the City for the Prime Minister, saying: “There is . . . running throughout the Report a deep hostility to government policy and the philosophy on which it is based.

“Its own approach is collectivist, determinist, and Keynesian. The inner-city problems will be solved through bigger government.”

The essence of “Marxist analysis” is that inequality is caused by conflict between the bourgeoisie against the proletariat, Mr Griffiths wrote. The Church’s report analyses the problems of poverty in “similar terms; namely the exploitation of ‘the poor’ (15 million) by ‘comfortable Britain’ (the rest).”

Another memo on the report submitted to Mrs Thatcher accused Faith in the City of being an “unwitting dupe of the extreme left”. Hartley Booth wrote that the chapter on law and order “could play a dangerous role in subverting support for hard-pressed forces of law and order, and in whipping up racial tensions.”

“The Church should learn how Lenin intended that a prime target of attack in a capitalist society should be the police,” he also said.

The report, which led to the creation of the Church Urban Fund and addressed many of its recommendations at the Church of England, not just the state, sparked a major row with the Government.

The report highlighted what it saw as the Government’s “dogmatic and inflexible” economic policies, and lamented the “unacceptable” impact of high unemployment.

Although Labour MPs described it as “magnificent” in parliamentary debates, the Conservative MP Nicholas Fairbairn said it was a "wretched document . . . hubristic, sanctimonious, self-righteous, and irreligious".

Writing in the Church Times for the 25th anniversary of the publication of Faith in the City, Prebendary Pat Dearnley, who was appointed by Archbishop Runcie to lead the Church’s response to the report, said that the criticism by the Thatcher government generated more publicity for the Church’s findings than would have otherwise occurred (Comment, 1 December 2010).

A Church Times leading article concluded that the Archbishop’s Commission that produced Faith in the City had done a "major and radical job" in bringing together so much insight into the "challenge of Britain’s new ghettos".

"What they have to say may often seem disturbing to a Church which is predominantly middle-class, still substantially rural and almost entirely white.

"To ignore it or to ridicule it would merely be to encourage the Militant Tendency, the National Front, and other extremist bodies which now aim at the destruction not only of the nation’s basic consensus but also of the nation’s whole tradition."

Job of the week

Assistant Chaplain & UK Director

London and Home Counties

Zacharias Trust Assistant Chaplain & UK Director Salary: £45,000-£47,500 plus benefits (experience dependent) Oxford (37.5 hours per week) We have an exciting opportunity for an Assist...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

Making money work for others

Making money work for others

Continuing our Lent series on aspects of money, Matthew Bishop explores the links between philanthropy and faith  Subscribe to read more

Top comment

Doing without bacon rolls and paintball

To base ‘men’s ministry’ on tired stereotypes is not necessary, and may be unhelpful, argues Anne Bennett  Subscribe to read more

Wed 29 Mar 17 @ 9:56
Find it on iTunes, Soundcloud and other podcast platforms:

Tue 28 Mar 17 @ 20:29
Listen to the first episode of the Church Times Podcast- The latest on the Llandaff row & @malcolmguite on Coleridge