*** DEBUG END ***

Searching the hearts of voters

18 November 2016

Pat Ashworth reports from New England on Trump supporters’ priorities and principles


Stuck: Trump supporters think that they have found someone who can fix their problems

Stuck: Trump supporters think that they have found someone who can fix their problems

THERE are things below the surface in the United States which can still surprise the onlooker. Staying with friends during election time last week, I found myself sitting in a bus shelter in Hartford, Connecticut, eating pizza on the hoof while waiting for entry to the house of Harriet Beecher Stowe, the author of Uncle Tom’s Cabin.

There were four of us, all white and of a certain age. As cars went by, their occupants pointed and smiled. A black woman wound down the window and waved. I waved back. “Four white people waiting for a bus? That doesn’t happen here,” my hosts said in explanation.

So race remains an undercurrent, I observe — even in a state such as this, which went resoundingly to the Democrats; even here, in the very shadow of the abolitionists.

I lingered over the colourful book illustrations in the Beecher Stowe library. “Uncle Tom, would you like to be back in Kentucky with your family?” the saintly and fragile child, Eva, says, cushioned in the big man’s arms.

”I would, Little Eva, but I can’t,” he says with what looks like a breaking heart.


IT HAS been an unsettling couple of weeks. Not full of the razzmatazz I had expected: no, even on election night itself, there was a curious lack of all that, a reticence in some places that was almost furtive.

In busy Boston, the city that fought the battle for “no taxation without representation”, a noisy contingent of baseball-capped Trump supporters, all older men, stood on a street corner and yelled to cars to hoot in solidarity. A couple did so, and one passer-by muttered, “Dump Trump” in response; but, for the most part, people walked by without glance or comment. Since then, though, it has livened up, becoming the stage for more protests against the President-elect in the days since the vote.

What was drawing huge crowds in the city, however, was a gang of break-dancers on the marketplace outside Faneuil Hall, a “cradle of liberty since 1743”. Agile, rubber-limbed, they tumbled, spun, and walked on one hand, but it was the patter that was remarkable. This was an audacious, non-politically correct delivery, and the audience relaxed into it with palpable relief.

”Stand back because he’s now going to run at 80 miles an hour — something we black guys only do when we’re being chased by the cops,” the leader says.

They select people of every age and colour: “We need an Asian guy — come on you, Asian guy,” they say, pulling a bashful Korean out of the crowd. And telling kids to stay away from drugs and guns, they assess the smiling, sheepish line-up, and declare that this is humanity, here is humanity, we are all just humanity — before impossibly leapfrogging over a line of bodies, to deafening applause.


I REFLECT that that is the most honest, most uplifting thing that I witnessed in a fortnight of saturation TV coverage. I remain astounded at how the oft-quoted “white Evangelicals” and “churchgoers” were able to express strident views on issues such as abortion, but seemed too constrained to acknowledge the gospel imperative to love your neighbour, welcome the outcast and the stranger, and bring good news to the poor. How could they hold in tension all that they knew about Mr Trump, square that with the gospel, and vote for him?

This hit me most powerfully as I watched one of the final and most telling television ads sponsored by Hillary Clinton. Called “Role Models”, it showed in close-up the faces of children silently watching and listening to Mr Trump’s worst pronouncements: defaming Mexicans; mocking people with disabilities; boasting “I could stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot someone, and wouldn’t lose any voters;” telling opponents that they could “go fuck themselves”. A question was posed: what principles did people want our children to live by?

This should be a question for the Churches. Who are these white Evangelicals, 81 per cent of whom voted for Mr Trump?

A woman described in a newspaper report as “a lifelong Democrat, a church-going single mother who practises yoga and doesn’t eat meat”, voted for him because she thought him “a strong leader who would get things done”, and because it was “nice he was taking care of the vets” [veterans]. Others saw the thrice-married Mr Trump as a “good father with a beautiful family”.


NO ONE should discount the valid reasons why people voted for Mr Trump. David Brooks, a respected columnist for The New York Times, put it neatly: “It is true that those voters were willing to tolerate a lot more bigotry in their candidate than I’d be willing to tolerate.

”But if you were stuck in a jobless town, watching your friends OD on opiates, scrambling every month to pay the electricity bill, and then along came a guy who seemed able to fix your problems and hear your voice, then maybe you would stomach some ugliness, too.”

Christians quoted in The Washington Post believed the election to have shown the underbelly of the toxic relationship that could develop between politics and religion.

Seeing Mr Trump as the antithesis of Christian behaviour, many now fear lasting damage done to the perception of Christianity in the United States. There is much heart-searching for the years ahead.

Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Letters to the editor

Letters for publication should be sent to letters@churchtimes.co.uk.

Letters should be exclusive to the Church Times, and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear below your letter unless requested otherwise.

Forthcoming Events

Green Church Awards

Awards Ceremony: 6 September 2024

Read more details about the awards


Festival of Preaching

15-17 September 2024

The festival moves to Cambridge along with a sparkling selection of expert speakers

tickets available



Festival of Faith and Literature

28 February - 2 March 2025

The festival programme is soon to be announced sign up to our newsletter to stay informed about all festival news.

Festival website


ViSIt our Events page for upcoming and past events 

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times


To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)