*** DEBUG END ***

Not a judge or a fudge, but a nudge

15 April 2016

Pope Francis has become the first true Vatican II pontiff, says Paul Vallely

“WHO am I to fudge?” should, in the opinion of one conservative wag, be Pope Francis’s new catchphrase, after the publication of his encyclopaedic new document on love and the family, Amoris Laetitia. Rigorists who had hoped for hard-line clarity have been disappointed, as have liberals who hoped that he would approve same-sex marriage, and issue an edict permitting all Roman Catholics who had divorced and married again to receive holy communion. But all this misses what is really revolutionary about this apostolic exhortation.

Certainly, Amoris Laetitia (“The Joy of Love”) is a document of such breadth that it purposefully allows for a certain ambiguity. Conservatives can find in it unequivocal affirmation of the indissolubility of marriage. Liberals can see repeated distinctions between doctrinal ideals and pastoral compassion: condemning the sin, but loving the sinner. The Pope dismisses phrases such as “living in sin”, insisting that sin cannot be determined by a scrutiny of external circumstance. Not everything that looks “irregular” has sin in its heart.

And he deals with the communion ban only in footnotes, where he insists that “sacramental discipline”, too, must be subject to the same discernment. Conservatives assert that the Pope is spreading confusion — their thinly veiled code for anything he says that they disagree with. Liberals say that his phrase that the eucharist “is not a prize for the perfect, but a powerful . . . nourishment for the weak” opens the door for the communion ban to be lifted.

What all this overlooks is that Amoris Laetitia is breaking new ground in an entirely different way. The Pope’s concern is not to change the rules, but to change his Church. Previous popes have used post-synod exhortations to issue definitive new positions on the subject in hand. Pope Francis has gone out of his way not to be definitive. This document comes after a three-year process involving an unprecedented questionnaire of lay people, two synods, and a year of worldwide debate. Amoris Laetitia quotes from those synods more than 200 times, as well as from numerous documents by bishops’ conferences around the world. It quotes from Protestants and secularists, too.

Uniquely, it makes statements such as “Not all discussions of doctrinal, moral or pastoral issues need to be settled by interventions of the magisterium.” It adds: “Neither the Synod nor this Exhortation could be expected to provide a new set of general rules, canonical in nature and applicable to all cases.” Instead, it speaks of discernment, the primacy of conscience, and the need for “each country or region” to “seek solutions better suited to its culture and sensitive to its traditions and local needs”.

What this amounts to is the first practical application of the Second Vatican Council’s call for a return to a more collegial Church. The Pope is no longer monarch, but a bishop among bishops. As primus inter pares, he does not judge (or fudge), but rather is content to nudge. In this document, Pope Francis has shown himself to be the first true Vatican II pontiff.

He knows that this will disconcert “those who pre­fer a more rigorous pastoral care which leaves no room for confusion”. But he wants a more mature spirituality. He wants a Church for grown-ups.


Paul Vallely is the author of Pope Francis: The struggle for the soul of Catholicism (Bloomsbury, 2015).


Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Letters to the editor

Letters for publication should be sent to letters@churchtimes.co.uk.

Letters should be exclusive to the Church Times, and include a full postal address. Your name and address will appear below your letter unless requested otherwise.

Forthcoming Events

Green Church Awards

Awards Ceremony: 6 September 2024

Read more details about the awards


Festival of Preaching

15-17 September 2024

The festival moves to Cambridge along with a sparkling selection of expert speakers

tickets available


Inspiration: The Influences That Have Shaped My Life

September - November 2024

St Martin in the Fields Autumn Lecture Series 2024

tickets available



Festival of Faith and Literature

28 February - 2 March 2025

The festival programme is soon to be announced sign up to our newsletter to stay informed about all festival news.

Festival website


Visit our Events page for upcoming and past events 

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times


To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)