*** DEBUG START ***
*** DEBUG END ***

Answers, please

01 April 2016

iStock

IN A week when straight religious programmes asked big questions about eternity, infinity, and death, the most profound meditation of all came from the mouth of a self-pitying, cantankerous Irishwoman in pursuit of redemptive sympathy. Mrs Rooney — the central protagonist in Samuel Beckett’s All That Fall (Radio 4, Holy Saturday) — is not interested in the great theological questions. Given the rare opportunity to question a Regius Professor of Divinity, she asks whether Jesus rode into Jerusalem on an ass’s colt, or a hinny.

But her journey to and from the railway station, expressed in a mixture of uncharacteristic naturalism and absurdist ritual, takes on all the resonance of a tragic pilgrimage.

It is hard to imagine now a BBC prepared to commission a radio play such as Beckett’s All That Fall. But this was 1957, and this first drama after Waiting for Godot is as much a classic of the genre as Dylan Thomas’s Under Milk Wood, a few years earlier. In this new version, the director, Max Stafford-Clark, knocks off a good ten minutes from an original, which now sounds almost liturgical in its reverence for Beckett’s pace.

The slightly quicker delivery, combined with vastly more convincing sounds of the countryside, made this version a more appropriate entry-point for those encountering Beckett’s classic text for the first time.

Unlike Waiting for Godot, All That Fall concludes in melodramatic fashion. Yet there is for ever something menacing as well as mournful about Mrs Rooney’s journey. Schubert’s quartet “Death and the Maiden” provides a hint from the very start, and the death of children remains a leitmotif throughout.

At the conclusion of one of her disjointed anecdotes, Mrs Rooney quotes a doctor, speaking of a deceased girl in his care: “The trouble with her was that she had never really been born.” Like the best of Beckett, the line incorporates both a touching simplicity and a poetic profundity, drawing force from biblical allusion. It is good, once in a while, to be reminded of how good radio drama can be.

Pascal’s admission that he was terrified by “the eternal silence of infinite spaces” has a Beckettian ring to it. But the message of Anders Sandberg’s edition of The Essay (Radio 3, Holy Wednesday), in which Pascal was quoted, was not of fear but of aspiration: that, in response to ever lengthening life expectancy, we must teach ourselves to love life. Fear of death, he declared, was not a good enough reason to extend life.

We should take this man seriously; for he works at a place called The Future of Humanity Institute at Oxford University.

Sandberg was contributing to a series, Desperately Seeking Eternity, in which writers discussed how “modern technology threatens to undermine our traditional ideas”. Enterprising though these essays were, I am not sure that any of them convincingly demonstrated the premise, let alone how we might negotiate these challenges.

Naomi Anderson, for instance, told us about the mathematics of infinity, and how contemplation of larger and smaller infinities might help us with our understanding of God. But, as she demonstrated, this was not a modern concept: Spinoza was irritating people with just these ideas centuries ago.

Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Church Times Bookshop

Save money on books reviewed or featured in the Church Times. To get your reader discount:

> Click on the “Church Times Bookshop” link at the end of the review.

> Call 01603 785905 (Mon-Fri, 10am-4pm).

The reader discount is valid for two months after the review publication date. E&OE

Forthcoming Events

English Mystics Series course

26 January - 25 May 2026

A short course at Sarum College.

tickets available now

 

Springtime for the Church of England: where are we seeing growth?

31 January 2026

Join us at St John's Church, Waterloo to hear a group of experts speak about the Quiet Revival.

tickets available now

 

With All Your Heart: a retreat in preparation for Lent

14 February 2026

Church Times/Canterbury Press online retreat.

tickets available now

 

Merlin’s Isle: A Journey in Words and Music with Malcolm Guite and the St Martin's Voices

17 February 2026

Canterbury Press event at Temple Church, London. The Poet and Priest draws out the Christian bedrock at the heart of the Arthurian stories, revealing their spiritual depth and enduring resonance.

tickets available now

 

Visit our Events page for upcoming and past events

The Church Times Archive

Read reports from issues stretching back to 1863, search for your parish or see if any of the clergy you know get a mention.

FREE for Church Times subscribers.

Explore the archive

Welcome to the Church Times

To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read up to four free articles a month. (You will need to register.)