TOUCHED by Auschwitz (BBC2, Tuesday of last week),
marking the 70th anniversary of the liberation of the concentration
camp, was one of several documentaries broadcast last week on the
theme of the Holocaust. This one told the story of six surviving
inmates, and explored how their lives have unfolded over seven
decades.
What built up was the obvious but easily overlooked insight
that, despite the uniquely horrific experience that they shared in
their childhood and youth, they are all distinct individuals, with
different stories to tell: they cannot be lumped together in a
single entity.
One triumph of the film was to forbid us to label the victims as
an inseparable group. There may be a profound truth here: the
action of evil, of totalitarian hatred, is to destroy human
separateness, to treat all Jews, all Gypsies, all "degenerates" as
indistinguishable from each other.
Religious faith is by no means a constant factor in the
resilience of those depicted: a couple are deeply committed to
their beliefs - one in particular, who still works as a
psychiatrist counselling other survivors, is convinced that even
the hell of Nazi extermination must be part of God's deep plan,
which we will, at some time in the future, understand.
Others had every atom of religion destroyed by what they
experienced - but there are other kinds of faith. Perhaps the most
moving of the testimonies was Max's: he encountered one act of
kindness from a German guard, and has built his life around the
centrality of kindness to others. Thaddeus had one moment of
insight: you must do good to others, and has lived by that ever
since. These principles may seem trite, but, when forged in this
furnace of evil, they take on a new significance. Hermann, a Gypsy,
survived after the war only because of the hospitality of a French
family.
One constant theme was the next generation; how much should the
survivors recount their stories to their children? Should Auschwitz
be allowed to define your life, and theirs?
The overall conclusion, again, obvious and too easily
overlooked, is that it depends. The survivors had experienced
different horrors, and they are different people. They will react
differently. These individual stories helped us to reflect on how
we might react and deal with the experience of evil.
A different anniversary - 150 years since the publication of
Alice in Wonderland - produced The Secret Life of
Lewis Carroll (BBC2, Saturday). Trying to put to one side my
natural distaste for anything that besmirches the memory of a
brother Anglican clergyman, I nevertheless concluded that this was
essentially unsatisfactory.
Although constantly protesting that she was seeking a balanced
picture, Martha Kearney again and again returned to the theme of
the Revd Charles Lutwidge Dodgson's relationship with young girls.
Is speculation about repressed paedophilia really the most
important thing that can be said? Is it all that our prurient age
is interested in?
The experts who protested that such readings wholly
misunderstood 19th-century culture, and the actual evidence, were
swamped by those who found sex at every turn.