A CHURCH of Ireland rector has challenged the call from the UN
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights for another
referendum on abortion to ensure that Irish women and girls "can
fully realise their economic, social, and cultural rights".
The Rector of Castlecomer, in the diocese of Ossory, the Revd
Patrick Burke, in a letter to the Irish Times, said that
the UN was powerless to order the Irish State in any of its
internal governance.
"Their 'must' is contained in a list of recommendations in a
report; and a recommendation is something that can just as easily
be rejected as accepted," he wrote. "So, really, this is less a
'must' than a 'This is what we think you should do,' said in a
hectoring tone accompanied by a frowning look and lot of
finger-wagging.
"That makes a lot more sense. After all, the last time I looked,
the UN didn't have the authority to dictate to member states how
they manage their internal affairs; and certainly none of its
multitude of committees doesn't have that power. Therefore, the
only thing we 'must' do with this report and its recommendations is
politely nod and smile, and then do as we ourselves see fit."
On Monday, the Irish Health Minister, Leo Varadkar, said that 26
terminations were carried out last year under the Protection of
Life During Pregnancy Act 2013, 14 of them due to risk of life of
the mother from physical illness; a further nine on the basis of
what were termed "emergency situations"; and three because of the
risk that the women would take their own lives.
Reacting, Amnesty International reiterated its call for a new
referendum on the "right to life of the unborn" which is enshrined
in the Constitution. The director of Amnesty International Ireland,
Colm O'Gorman, said of the Minister's report: "Nothing in it
suggests that the multiple processes a woman or girl may have to
undergo to be deemed entitled to an abortion are respectful of
their human rights, including their right to health."
On Monday, one of the best-known campaigners in Ireland against
abortion, Bernadette Smyth, won an appeal at Belfast County
Court against her conviction for harassment of a Marie Stopes
director at the city centre clinic.
Mrs Smyth was convicted by magistrates in November of conducting
a campaign against Dawn Purvis, who is also a former Progressive
Unionist Party MLA.
Mrs Smyth was ordered to undertake 100 hours' community service,
and to pay compensation of £2000 to Ms Purvis. The appeal judge,
Gordon Kerr, said that the evidence did not meet the standards for
a successful prosecution.
Judge Kerr confirmed on Monday that Mrs Smyth would not be
subject to any further restraining order relating to the case.