I WAS at a conference called Leading Your Church Into
Growth (LYCIG) at the Swanwick Conference Centre, checking out the
materials for use in Southwark diocese, where I am Missioner.
The materials were very good, and over dinner I found myself
talking to a couple of others at the conference who were also
residentiary canons of cathedrals. We agreed that what was missing
was something specifically for cathedrals. And so LYCathIG was
born.
On the train home, I sent an email around the diocesan
missioners' network with the idea. By the next morning, more than
half of the cathedrals or dioceses of the Church of England had
been in touch to express an interest.
I shouldn't have been surprised. When the church research report
From Anecdote to Evidence was published early in 2014, it
highlighted two particular parts of the Church that are
experiencing numerical growth. These were Fresh Expressions of
Church, and cathedral congregations. (The report makes no claim
that this is the only type of growth that matters, but it is the
type of growth that the project was set up to research.)
And yet, although I work in a cathedral where the congregation
is numerically strong, I suspect that we are fairly typical in
having no particular strategy to grow the congregation. We see
people come, and we rejoice that they do, but we don't necessary
know why they do. (A handful of cathedrals, including Southwark,
have undertaken their own research on this with Professor Leslie
Francis; so we may know a little more shortly.)
THUS the Cathedrals and Growth Network was created, to draw
together Chapter representatives from as many of our cathedrals as
wanted to take part to learn from each other about congregational
growth. All are welcome: anyone who has a shared responsibility and
interest for enabling numerical growth, evangelism, and
discipleship, even while we acknowledge that this is not the only
kind of growth with which cathedrals are concerned.
The Network gathered for our first meeting at Southwark
Cathedral last month, with representation from more than half the
English cathedrals. We heard from Kevin Norris, of the Strategy and
Development Unit, on the From Anecdote to Evidence
research and its findings on cathedral growth, and then spent the
afternoon in workshop groups talking about the key growth factors
we observed in our own contexts, and how they differed from some of
the popular perceptions of cathedral attendance - perceptions that
are also being challenged by the research.
ONE of these perceptions is that people come to cathedrals in
search of anonymity. I remember the rural dean at my first
deanery-synod meeting after ordination bemoaning the introduction
of coffee after the service as the time the Church of England lost
its way. "I don't want to drink coffee and chat," he cried. "I just
want to say my prayers and go home."
It is sometimes said that people are motivated to attend
cathedral worship by a similar desire. But it's not true. Asked why
they attend, one of the commonest responses people give is that
they like the friendly atmosphere and the opportunity to make
friends. One might contend that some choose cathedrals because
their own parish is insufficiently friendly, too cliquey, or with
too narrow a range of people, and not enough chances to make
friends.
THIS leads to another perception, that cathedral growth is
primarily transfer growth, i.e. that cathedrals are leeching off
the local parishes to which people would otherwise go.
The picture is generally different. Many attending cathedrals
were formerly unchurched, that is to say, they had never previously
been a regular worshipper anywhere. A larger group were formerly
dechurched, people who had once been regular churchgoers but who
were not going anywhere immediately before coming to the
cathedral.
Yes, there is a large group of people who had been going to a
church, but transferred. It is interesting to find out why. Mostly,
this is not because people prefer to be less visible, or to have
less asked of them than in the parish. This is, of course, true of
a few, as it is in any large, well-resourced church: just ask Holy
Trinity, Brompton.
But, more typically, people leave their parish for a cathedral
because something has gone wrong. They have been hurt or damaged
somehow, and the cathedral provides a safe place where they can
regroup and recover.
Some will stay; some will go back, or go on to somewhere else.
Again, this is a pattern that any large church can identify with.
But cathedrals allow some to leave their parish without leaving the
Church. In that way, we are the Church's hospital, or recovery
room.
FINALLY, there is a common perception that people come to
cathedrals for glorious music, stunning architecture, a sense of
history and heritage - but not for spiritual growth. Leaving aside
the question of whether these things are opposed, the research
suggests spiritual growth is happening in cathedrals.
Many give testimony to how their faith has come to life in a
cathedral congregation. Real evangelism and discipleship, the focus
of so much of our thinking and talking these days, is taking place
in cathedrals.
So what does enable cathedrals to grow? The workshops at our
first gathering suggested two factors above all others, which
fortunately resonate with the research. The first is missional
intentionality. Cathedrals need a clear and declared intention to
grow, to enable growth, and to place their resources
accordingly.
The second is multiple opportunities to worship in a variety of
ways. Messy Church, fresh expressions, as well as evensong and the
eucharist, increase the range of people who can find a spiritual
home in a cathedral.
In that way, maybe cathedrals aren't so different from other
churches after all.
The Revd Dr Stephen Hance is Canon Missioner, Southwark
Cathedral, and Director of Mission and Evangelism for Southwark
diocese.