THE form may have been diminished by endless parodies, but there
is still something thrilling about a traditional investigative
documentary. The thrill of the chase, the late-night stake-outs,
and the final confrontation - it is what journalists used to
do.
Stories in Sound (Radio Ulster, Thursday of last week)
felt like a blast from the past. We heard the Northern Ireland
reporter Andy Pag on the trail of people-traffickers, in a piece
that combined revelation with a critique of the forthcoming law in
Northern Ireland to criminalise payment for sex. The title,
Vice Girl or Victim?, set out the issue: although many
young women could technically be said to enter into the sex trade
by consent, there is, with most, a high level of coercion arising
from financial circumstances.
Pag's investigation focused on the influx of Chinese women into
Belfast, answering ads for masseurs - and, for the most part,
knowing what extra services "massage" entailed. In a simple but
effective sting, he confronted a ringleader, and, microphone in
hand, chased her down the street, bombarding her with embarrassing
questions.
This sort of thing will always be great radio, but the wider
question - whether the new legislation will make debt-ridden
migrant workers more desperate - remained hanging. With an economic
downturn in China, it is hard to see how the destinies of women
such as "Fay", or "Lynn", featured here, are going to improve.
An émigré story in a somewhat less depressing vein was that of
Arthur Orton - or, as he would have it, Sir Roger Tichborne.
Friday's edition of The Essay (Radio 3, weekdays)
recounted how Orton, a Wapping butcher who had emigrated to Wagga
Wagga, Australia, almost succeeded in claiming the Tichborne family
inheritance.
Orton's campaign of deceit began with what might seem the most
unpromising of strategies: he sent a photograph of himself to Lady
Tichborne, the elderly widow who had initiated a search for her
estranged son.
Remarkably, she welcomed her "long-lost son" with open arms; and
thus began one of the longest and most expensive cases in British
legal history, lasting from 1867 to 1874. For the Radio 3 essayist
Jennifer Tucker, the interest lay in the status of the photograph
as witness to the truth. These were the early days of photography,
before we routinely questioned the veracity of the images.
It also raised discussion about whether a man's physical
appearance and moral character might change, in keeping with
diminished and degrading circumstances. The case of "The Tichborne
Claimant" became a case-study in the nature-versus-nurture
debate.
A parallel case-study of breeding and environment might be
conducted at the Hollywood Cricket Club, where the manners and
gentility of the great English game are practised amid the dazzle
of the film industry. In Sports Hour (World Service,
Saturday), we heard about this eccentric partnership of English
mores and LA glitz, initiated in the 1930s by the English actor C.
Aubrey Smith, and continued by the likes of Hugh Grant and Mick
Jagger. Even the grass seed in the playing area is imported from
Blighty.