LEADERS in faith and science were united last week in praise of
the encyclical letter Laudato Si' [God be praised]: On care for
our common home, Pope Francis's "powerful intervention" on the
degradation of the earth.
Among those welcoming the encyclical, published on Thursday of
last week, was the head of the UN's environment programme, Achim
Steiner, who said that it "clarion call that resonates not only
with Catholics, but with all of the earth's peoples. Science and
religion are aligned on this matter: the time to act is now."
The head of campaigns at Friends of the Earth, Andrew Pendleton,
said that the Pope had "shown impressive and inspiring leadership
where many elected leaders have failed".
In Laudato Si' the Pope writes: "Many of those who
possess more resources and economic or political power seem mostly
to be concerned with masking the problems, or concealing their
symptoms, simply making efforts to reduce some of the negative
impacts of climate change." Nothing less than a "bold cultural
revolution" will do, given that "we may well be leaving to coming
generations debris, desolation, and filth."
Although he acknowledges that business is a "noble vocation,
directed to producing wealth and improving our world", and says
that he is not anti-modernity - "Nobody is suggesting a return to
the Stone Age" - he is scathing about the bail-out of the banks and
"short-sighted approaches to the economy, commerce, and
The most one can expect of this powerful group, he writes, is
"superficial rhetoric, sporadic acts of philanthropy, and
perfunctory expressions of concern for the environment, whereas any
genuine attempt by groups within society to introduce change is
viewed as a nuisance based on romantic illusions, or an obstacle to
To those in favour of population control he says: "To blame
population growth instead of extreme and selective consumerism on
the part of some, is one way of refusing to face the issues"; and
he gives a critique of modern ills, including a prevalent
"throwaway culture" and "rampant individualism".
Although the document states that the Roman Catholic Church
"does not presume to settle scientific questions", the Pope refers
to a "very solid scientific consensus" about global warming, and to
studies suggesting that it is mostly caused by human activity.
Fossil fuels must be "progressively replaced without delay", he
Greenpeace's international executive director, Kumi Naidoo,
called the encyclical "a welcome rebuke to climate-change deniers
and the interests that seek to thwart progress. . . The Pope's
words should jolt heads of government out of their complacency, and
encourage them to bring in tough laws in their own countries to
protect the climate, and to agree a strong climate protocol in
Paris at the end of this year."
Christians in Science welcomed the work as a "powerful
intervention", informed by "the very distinguished atmospheric
scientists in the papal academy".
Anglican leaders welcomed the Pope's intervention. The
Archbishop of Cape Town, the Rt Revd Thabo Makgoba, gave examples
of the effects of climate change already seen in Africa and
developing countries, including floods in Mozambique and droughts
"In drawing attention to the high levels of consumption, greed,
and wastefulness in our world . . . the encyclical makes clear that
we need to adopt simpler, more wholesome lifestyles," he said.
Other Christian groups added cautionary notes to their welcome
for the encyclical. The chairman of the charity Green Christian,
Paul Bodenham, said that it was vital that it spurred reform of
Catholic Social Teaching, which "has developed in an ecological
vacuum, and is simply not fit for the 21st-century predicament".
The charity is critical of the "technocratic notion of 'stewardship
A divestment campaigner at Operation Noah, Ellie Roberts,
expressed a hope that it would "inspire Catholic communities around
the world to look at how their own investments might be financing
The head of international climate politics at Greenpeace, Martin
Kaiser, said that he hoped that the Vatican bank would divest from
coal, oil, and nuclear power and support renewables. Others gave
examples of work already under way to implement the Pope's call to
Christian Aid's principal Climate Change Adviser, Dr Alison
Doig, gave examples of work by its partners, including the use in
Malawi of improved stoves to reduce deforestation, and
flood-warning systems in the Philippines.
But Jeb Bush, the Republican presidential candidate in the
United States, said: "I hope I'm not going to get castigated for
saying this by my priest back home, but I don't get economic policy
from my bishops, or my cardinal, or my pope."
The venue for the UK launch was Our Lady and St Joseph's
Catholic Primary School, in Poplar, east London, which opened in
September last year. It has been constructed from timber and brick,
and uses solar energy. It is in one of the most deprived parts of
the country, near Canary Wharf and the country's financial
The President of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and
Wales, Cardinal Vincent Nichols, said that the document contained
enough to "disquiet some people behind me".
Laudato Si': a digest by the Bishop of Sheffield, Dr
THE Pope's encyclical letter is addressed to the whole of
humankind, not only Roman Catholics, and not simply Christians. He
writes: "I wish to address every living person on the planet."
His plea is for the whole human family to come together at this
key moment in our history to seek sustainable development across
the earth. The letter describes what is happening to our common
home, and draws out the clear consequences for human life.
All of these developments disproportionately affect the poorest
nations. The poor should be at the heart of our concern for the
environment, and the two cannot be separated.
Chapter Two of the letter sets out a clear and detailed basis
for Christians (and others) to renew their commitment to the earth,
rooted in scripture and the doctrine of creation.
Chapter Three explores the human roots of the ecological crisis.
Our technical prowess has brought us to a crossroads. We have
placed ourselves at the centre of the universe, as masters of
creation, and failed to understand what life is for.
A better and more profound understanding is needed. We are not
isolated individuals, but part of the larger universe, and in a
particular place within it.
In Chapter Four, the Pope explores environmental, economic, and
social ecology, cultural ecology, and the ecology of daily life.
Environmental degradation is a consequence of the human condition,
not an accident of it.
In Chapter Five, he turns to lines of approach and action. These
are to be rooted in Christian hope, and the expectation that things
can change. He highlights the importance of dialogue on the
environment in the international community, and the forthcoming
climate-change conference in Paris, but also the need to bring
economics politics, science, and religions into conversation at a
In the sixth and final chapter, the letter turns to what we
ourselves can do. We are to be partners, not observers, in this
Lifestyle is key, as we each learn to live sustainable lives.
Education is vital in schools, homes, and seminaries. He uses the
term "ecological conversion"; part of our discipleship is
recovering our responsibility to the earth.
But individual action is not enough. Love must lead us to
political action as well, to act in hope to renew the mindset of
the world, and reform our stewardship of the earth.
The encyclical letter Laudato Si' can be
found on the
Faith and climate
reach outwards - Religion and approaches to the earth
are not just inner concerns, argues Andrew
The smell of burning
paper - Press review
Pope's encyclical blames 'extreme consumerism' for the planet's
ills - last week's full report
on Laudato Si'