CUSTOMS and traditions have a life of their own, and Mothering
Sunday is no exception. It does no harm to remind people of its
church connections - the return of domestic servants and labourers
to their mother church and, coincidentally, their own mothers; the
association with Christ's mother - and the ubiquitous posies are a
great draw for family services. In practice, though, the day is
about showing appreciation and gratitude to individual mothers, in
recognition of the prime part they play in rearing their children.
Gifts, flowers, and cards are small recompense for the years of
work and anxiety, let alone the burden of childbirth; but the
genuineness of the thanks is what gives them value, and overrides
the commercial promptings and directions of taste down questionable
pathways. The gratitude also helps to offset the inadequacy felt by
most mothers, who are acutely conscious of their failings as
carers. It is good to be reminded of how forgiving children can
be.
It would be helpful if there were some way of developing
Mothering Sunday into a celebration of parents in general without
its sounding earnest and humourless. Father's Day, judging by the
illustrations on most of the cards, remains a celebration of adult,
male pursuits: golf, fishing, sailing, drinking, and the like. A
father's part in the upbringing of his children is still poorly
acknowledged. Perceptions are changing rapidly, but the centuries
of uneven parenting continue to cast a shadow over the present. A
Parenting Sunday, were it not such a dreadful phrase, could do much
to highlight the complementary - indeed, largely identical - tasks
and responsibilities taken on by mothers and fathers.
To set this in a church context would be to invite comparisons
with the love and care that God has for humanity. It is impossible
to conceive of this love as genderless: when God chose to appear as
a human on earth, he had to be one sex or another. Acts of
parenting are performed by either a male or a female. Yet there is
a danger of associating God too closely with the assumed
characteristics of one gender or another. Every aspect of human
love has a shadow side: the motherly attentiveness that smothers,
the fatherly instruction that domineers. And both mothers and
fathers are capable of neglect and cruelty, if seldom on the scale
of that meted out to Ayesha Chowdhury, for which her mother was
this week imprisoned for 13 years and her lover for 18. The saddest
aspect of the case was the discovery of Ayesha's letters in which
she berates herself for the naughtiness that, she thought, led to
the beatings that preceded her death. There is no shadow side to
God's love, no partiality, no selfishness. God's love overwhelms
distinctions between mothers and fathers, lovers, friends, and
siblings. All can draw on it indiscriminately.