THE impartiality of the BBC is a principle closely patrolled.
Scripts and cue-sheets of producers and presenters will often carry
a reminder of the disclaimer that the views expressed by X or Y are
their own, and not those of the Corporation. So, when Radio 3
launched into what, to some, might represent a political cause, we
entered interesting territory.
The cause was gender equality in classical music, prompted by
International Women's Day last Sunday. A week of programming, with
features on female musicians, led us up to the day itself, which
was dedicated solely to the work of women composers. The righting
of an obvious wrong, or political correctness gone mad? It appears
that most of those prepared to express an opinion were all for it
(no mean feat, since Radio 3 listeners can be a grumpy lot).
I should at this point admit to some partial interest in all of
this: I was a guest on an eclectic edition of The Choir,
which featured the girls' choir of St Catharine's College,
Cambridge, and the all-female punk band Gaggle. Despite the fact
that our host on this occasion was Sara Mohr-Pietsch, I am bound to
report that her contribution to Music Matters, on
Saturday, got closest to an appropriate sense of indignation
regarding women's inclusion in music.
The particular focus of this report was the opportunities given
to women composers in the 21st century. While the lack thereof in
previous centuries is the job of cultural historians to
investigate, the continuing deficit is something that all who are
interested in the arts should concern themselves with. It was
genuinely surprising to hear that six of the main music publishers
have only between three per cent and 17 per cent women on their
books. That many of these publishing houses are run by women points
to the kind of gender segregations discussed here by Dr Christina
Scharff; another instance is the proliferation of female music
teachers in schools, and the lack of them in conservatoires.
I could have done with more of this type of analysis - not least
because the music profession offers interesting case-studies in
gender inequality. This is not to belittle the historical features
that reminded us of the ways in which women have contributed to,
and been excluded from, classical music-making across the
centuries.
In The Sunday Feature: Convent to concert hall, Dr Kate
Kennedy introduced us to four instrumental virtuosi whose careers
blazed a trail, starting with the 18th-century Venetian violinist
Maddalena Lombardini. The story here is about Maddalena's education
in the Ospedale della Mendicanti, where orphan girls were trained
in a conservatoire atmosphere.
In the 19th century, an 18-year-old French cellist, Lise
Cristianti, gave concerts in Leipzig; and, in the 20th century, the
English cellist Beatrice Harrison was Elgar's favoured performer of
his Cello Concerto.
The quartet concluded with the violist and composer of chamber
music Rebecca Clarke - although many believed that "Rebecca Clarke"
was a pseudonym for a man, since women were known to be capable of
composing only light ditties.