WHETHER it is to explain why we like to get together of a
weekday evening and sing in choirs, or why we like to drink
ourselves silly of a weekend, it seems that, nowadays, people are
looking to evolutionary biology as the source of all wisdom.
So, in Trick or Trust (Radio 4, Tuesday of last week),
which promised an investigation of how Darwinian theory is being
employed by politicians to influence their policy-making, I was
looking forward to an exposé of bogus socio-scientific thinking: a
tale of the misuse and/or misunderstanding of evolutionary biology
in the interests of short-term pragmatism.
Sadly, this it was not. Daniel Finkelstein delivered a standard
discussion of the politics of altruism and reciprocity, served up
with an ultimately unsatisfactory garnish of science. For sure,
politicians are talking a great deal at the moment about the
"something for nothing" culture, identifying a deeply felt
sensibility within ourselves that everybody should contribute to
the public weal. But you do not need the Harvard mathematician
Professor Martin Nowak to understand this - still less, exemplars
invol-ving the socio-economics of air-conditioning.
You might even have suspected that this scientific garnish had
been deployed to mask some distasteful flavours. It was noticeable,
for instance, how easily British and American banking escaped
stricture, thanks to an apologist's declaring that the overriding
priority of the banks, post-crisis, had been to win back the
public's trust. But what has become patently clear, post-crisis, is
that the banking sector has no intention of reforming its
collective attitude or policies. It is a culture that appears to
operate according to an entirely different evolutionary model.
It is one of those subjects thatget the blood boiling. And there
are few comedians more cathartic than Marcus Brigstocke. Despite
the cartoonish stereotypes, there is a streak of anger that runs
through his new show, The Brig Society (Radio 4, Friday),
which, so long as you are in the mood for it, is wholly
compelling.
Being in the right mood means, of course, that you have to be
broadly in agreement with his politics; and a sociobiologist would
have something to say about a studio audience's guffawing as
Brigstocke aimed a series of insults at UKIP. But Brigstocke can be
profound when he wants to be, and last week the take-home message
was one worthy of any good political oration: "We're not
multi-cultural; we're cultural - the 'multi' is implicit."
Composers are notoriously indiscriminate when it comes to
summoning inspiration. Anything will do, so long as it produces
some notes to work with. So Playing the Skyline (Radio 4,
Monday), in which six musicians were asked to find music where the
land meets the sky, might have been an interest-ing examination of
the creative process.
Instead, the musical imaginations of Courtney Pine, James
MacMillan, and the like remain resolutely shut. What they produced
was generally pleasing, but their responses to the skylines they
were asked to transform into music reminded one of Polonius and
Hamlet discussing the shapes of clouds. It's all in the
looking.