Clergy are ‘more like Old Labour than New’
Posted: 31 Oct 2014 @ 00:29
A survey commissioned to
support debates on the future of the C of E yields some interesting
results, says Linda Woodhead
THE clergy of the Church of England clergy are a unique tribe.
Having lived and worked among them for extended periods, I long
suspected this might be true. Now, thanks to a new survey designed
with YouGov, I know just how true it is.
The survey was commissioned to support our new series of debates
on the future of the Church of England. In order to avoid any bias,
it was informed by a reference group drawn from across the Church.
It was completed by 1509 Church of England clergy aged 70 and
The results indicate that it is representative of all
churchmanships. When asked where they fall on a spectrum from
Evangelical to Catholic, roughly a third of clergy say they are at
the Evangelical end, a third at the Catholic end, and a third in
On a theologically liberal-to- conservative scale, 43 per cent
place themselves at the liberal end, 32 per cent in the middle, and
24 per cent at the conservative end. About a third of respondents
are female, and about third are under 55.
Two things unite this tribe. First, faith in a personal God.
Second, faith in the parish system (News,
The tribe is also marked by distinctive ethical and political
attitudes. One of the most surprising, given that it is not
official church teaching, is opposition to the current abortion
law: 16 per cent support an outright ban on abortion, and 43 per
cent would like to see a reduction in the 24-week time limit. By
contrast, only six per cent of all Anglicans, and the same
proportion of the general population, want a ban.
On euthanasia, however, the clergy are the inverse of other
Anglicans and the population as a whole. Whereas three-quarters of
the latter groups favour a relaxation of the law, almost the same
proportion of clergy (70 per cent) think that it should remain
unchanged. There is also some variance on same-sex marriage: 51 per
cent of clergy think it is wrong, compared with 47 per cent of all
Anglicans, and 37 per cent of the population.
But whereas the clergy are to the right of the population in
ethics, they are to the left in politics: Old Labour rather than
New. "I thought I was looking at UKIP," said a friend of mine
scanning the survey data, "until I got to the politics bit."
The left-lean is particularly evident in the clergy's
overwhelming commitment to a generous welfare state. They are three
times as likely as the general population to think that the welfare
budget is too low and should be increased (44 per cent of clergy,
15 per cent of the population). Similarly, less than a third of
clergy think that the current welfare system creates a culture of
dependency, compared with three-fifths of the population, and more
than two-thirds of Anglicans.
The clergy are also more positive - and completely opposed to
UKIP - in their attitudes to immigration and multiculturalism. On
the other hand, perhaps underlining their own sense of difference
from wider society, a surprisingly high proportion of clerics (51
per cent) believe that Christians today are being discriminated
against, by the Government and others, and by equality
Overall, then, Church of England clergy are distinguished from
"the people" by slightly more conservative moral attitudes and,
above all, by their strong commitment to God and to a generous
system of universal welfare. They uphold a vision of society in
which all are housed and provided for, irrespective of their
deserts - just as the clergy themselves are.
So far, so united. But, as well as these areas of convergence,
there are divisions. The most important is between the third of
clergy at the Evangelical end of the spectrum and the other
For example, a full 88 per cent of Evangelical clergy think that
same-sex marriage is wrong; and they make up more than half of the
16 per cent of clergy who want an outright ban on abortion.
Most striking of all, however, is the way that male clergy at
the Evangelical end of the spectrum differ about how to disagree.
When asked what sort of unity they consider appropriate for the
Church of England and the Anglican Communion (separate questions,
but similar answers are given to both), most of the "middle" and
Catholic clergy (73 per cent) agree that the goal is: "Maintaining
unity by being more tolerant of diverse views", and 61 per cent of
Evangelical women agree.
But most of the Evangelical clergy don't think this is a goal
worth pursuing. One third think that the Communion should "separate
amicably", and half think that greater uniformity should be imposed
So much for facilitated conversations aimed at "disagreeing
well". For the majority of Evangelical clergymen, the enterprise is
misguided from the start.
Linda Woodhead is Professor of Sociology of Religion at
Lancaster University, and organiser of the Westminster Faith Debate
series on "The Future of the Church of England".
All the figures, unless otherwise stated, come from YouGov
plc. Total sample size: 1509 Anglican clergy. Field- work
undertaken between 14 August and 9 September 2014. The survey was
carried out online. Figures for lay Anglicans and the general
population come from a survey carried out by YouGov for Westminster
Faith Debates in July 2013.