THE tercentenary of the birth of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach
(1714-88) falls this year. Johann Sebastian Bach's fifth child and
second son, he became one of the most prominent of the musicians of
the latter 18th century. It is often said, rightly, that his music
bridges the German Baroque and Viennese Classical periods (whereas
his younger brother Johann Christian, who taught the boy Mozart in
London, exemplifies the new musical era).
After three decades at the Prussian court of Frederick the
Great, C. P. E. Bach succeeded his godfather Telemann in the
prestigious post of Kantor at the Johanneum in Hamburg, assuming
responsibility for the music of five of the principal churches in
the north-German Hanseatic city.
His St John Passion, first heard in 1784, 60 years
after his father's famous version was first performed in Leipzig,
has just been edited and performed in Christchurch Priory,
Hampshire, and the Cadogan Hall, London, by the Ukrainian conductor
Kirill Karabits, with the BBC Singers and the Bournemouth Symphony
Orchestra.
Celebrations of C. P. E. Bach's choral output this year - the
wonderfully impressive and rewarding The Last Sorrows of Our
Saviour, The Israelites in the Wilderness, or Christ's
Ascent into Heaven, for instance - have proved pretty sparse,
although his impressive instrumental output has featured on the BBC
and elsewhere (the violinist Rachel Podger will lead an attractive,
all-C. P. E. lunchtime Prom in the Cadogan Hall on Monday 28 July
at 1 p.m.).
Credit, therefore, to Croydon Philharmonic Choir, who celebrated
C. P. E. with his bracing Magnificat (composed 1749) in
Croydon Minster last November; to Ludlow Choral Society, who
performed it in St Laurence's, Ludlow, during March; and to two
London choirs, Highgate Choral Society and the City Chorus, who
paid a similar articulate tribute to Bach's deserving son at All
Hallows', Gospel Oak, with the New London Orchestra conducted by
Ronald Corp, and in the Musicians' Church, St
Sepulchre-without-Newgate, Holborn.
What Karabits and the BBC Singers confirmed was that, had his
father and famous godfather not lived, C. P. E. Bach would still be
viewed with Handel, Graun, and Keiser as a musical giant of the
18th century. He undoubtedly was then. Only the feeble historical
awareness of 19th- and early-20th-century England has permitted his
undue eclipse.
The Ukrainian conductor, still in his mid-thirties and now at
the helm of the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, believes that we
should not make the same mistake.
Karabits discovered the manuscript of this Passion in
his home capital, Kiev, and has made of it a very performable
score. In the richly rewarding acoustic of Christchurch Priory, it
came across as a vibrant work. Helpful to this were the preparatory
works: not just Bach's Sinfonia in B flat, vividly launched,
beautifully paced by Karabits in the Adagio, and with a driven
presto finale that subsided into a delightful lilt; but, even more,
the Morning Song on the Celebration of Creation
(Morgengesang am Schöpfungsfeste), C. P. E.'s setting of
his friend the poet Friedrich Gottlieb Klopstock sublime text
comparable to the theistic visions of Hölderlin ("Holy one! August
one! First one! The bright Sirius of the Earth").
Its opening Adagio, with aching cellos and basses, anticipates
Haydn's Creation: it bore influence: a copy surfaced among
Beethoven's belongings. The whole undertaking was enriched by the
singing of the BBC Singers' sopranos; when they were joined by two
Baroque-sounding flutes, the effect was miraculous. Indeed
"Herr! Herr! Gott! barmherzig, und gnädig" might easily
have been by Haydn himself - a clear measure of how C. P. E.'s
music points both forwards and backwards. This Passion
dates from just two years before Mozart's The Marriage of
Figaro.
A fluent and sympathetic narrator/Evangelist, Robin Tritschler,
abetted by articulate cello and organ continuo, helpedlift this
performance to a sublime level. The noble Christus, Michael Bundy,
lent reassurance and a tangible beauty to Bach's setting of
Christ's words, from his reproach to Peter at Gethsemane ("Put up
thy sword") to the darkly beautiful final aria "Wenn ich keinen
Trost mehr habe". When he ascends - C. P. E., as it
were, abjuring his father's setting - at "Es ist
vollbracht", there was an almost Schoenbergian sinister feel:
compare the latter's tragic epitaph A Survivor from
Warsaw.
The chorus was predictably fine: their dancing response to
Pilate, "We have no king but Caesar" and the whooping "Let us not
rend it but cast lots for it" were typical of their buoyant
reading. Karabits's choice of pacing for "Der Gerechte stirbt
fur uns Übertreter'" ("The just one dies for us misguided
ones; on Golgotha Heaven is coming to rest") rendered this one of
the most moving passages in the entire evening. Indeed, his
expressive hands in shaping the a cappella chorales reveal
him as a choral conductor of extraordinary purity, power, and
intensity.
Not all of the work is original: like Handel, Bach reworked some
of his own material, and here he borrows in part from his godfather
Telemann. It does mean there is possibly a slight lack of dramatic
thrust and cogency to the work, but this did not detract from the
joy of the performance.
The Christchurch Priory Music and Arts Festival runs from 15
to 21 June, and includes a performanceof Mendelssohn's Elijah
at 7.30 p.m. on Saturday 21
June.www.christchurchpriory.org
Motets by C. P. E. Bach, J. S. Bach, and Gottfried Homilius
will be performed by the Collegium Singers in St Peter and St Paul,
South Petherton, Somerset, on Saturday 5 July at 7.30 p.m.
www.collegiumsingers.org.uk