THE Reformation never took place - or so you might reasonably
conclude from the first episode of A Very British
Renaissance (BBC2, Friday). James Fox is eager to tell us
that, from the early 16th century, there was, in these islands, a
remarkable flowering of every aspect of culture - painting,
architecture, literature, science - which, he considers, is
popularly underrated, but this is because he denigrates all that
took place previously.
This is an extraordinary position - almost that of 18th-century
Whiggery, where "Gothic" meant "barbaric". It flies in the face, I
understand, of recent historical study, which is discovering
mounting evidence of the vigour of late-medieval creativity, and
its potential for further development.
Worse than that, he seems unwilling to give an adequate
historical context for the cultural movements of the period, to
which, of course, the climactic upheavals of the Protestant
Reformation were central. For example, he bewails the lack of
painting in medieval England, without mentioning that nearly all
Gothic art had been in the service of the Church, and that untold
pictures and wall-paintings were destroyed by the reformers.
He reminds us, quite properly, of the way that Foxe's Book of
Mar-tyrs moulded the religious attitude of the English for a couple
of centuries; what he does not mention is that the persecution of
Protestants under Bloody Mary, which it sternly records, had been
preceded by the barbarism of Henry VIII's and Edward VI's murder of
those who refused to deny the Pope; and that there had been
widespread popular support for the old religion, which surely
enabled ordinary people to participate in art than was allowed by
the Puritans.
The glories of Renaissance art seem to me to flower essentially
among an élite: the Reformation took away from the general populace
the opportunity to contribute towards new wall-paintings in their
parish church. Dr Fox celebrates the splendour of Tallis's Spem
in alium, but dismisses (perhaps he does not know about it)
the glories of the Eton Choirbook. It is perfectly possible to
think that both are wonderful.
More cutting-edge research can be savoured in the latest series
by the palaeontologist Richard Fortey, Fossil Wonderlands:
Nature's hidden treasures (BBC4, Tuesdays). He is focusing on
sites where especially significant finds have been made - specimens
that help us to understand key developments in the study of
evolution.
Professor Fortey is the most genial of guides, ending each
programme with the delicious conceit of sitting down and tucking
into a meal made from the nearest living relatives of some of the
fossils he has been showing us.
W1A (BBC2, Wednesdays) isa new spoof-documentary series
from the team that brought us Twenty Twelve; but this time
the target is the BBC itself. Ian Fletcher is the new Head of
Values, whose task is to discern exactly what the BBC is for. Once
again, a merciless laser dissects the inanities of
corporation-speak, of institutional nonsense, of modish
incompetence, and of the paramount significance of branding. It is
excruciating and funny - but not as sharp as the original.