MANY Church Times readers will want to get their "I
told you so" T-shirts out of the wardrobe after hearing The
Report (R4, Thursday) last week. The subject was the Big
Society: the big idea deployed in 2010 to give some semblance of
vision to the makeshift reality of coalition. Plenty of people, in
this paper and elsewhere, pointed out that in many places, and with
the help of many organisations, Society was already Big. But it
took several millions of pounds of misspent money before the
Government acknowledged this truth.
The particular stimulus for Simon Cox's report was a recent
inquiry by the National Audit Office criticising the allocation of
funds to a handful of significant projects promoted under the Big
Society banner which have failed badly. The tales make one
wince.
The Britain's Personal Best initiative, which aimed at becoming
the UK's biggest annual charity event, was closed down when only a
fraction of the numbers expected turned up. Your Square Mile
boasted that they would recruit a million members in the first year
- and managed only 64. And the CEO, in robust defence of his
organisation, was unable to get the project website to work when
asked by our pesky reporter.
There have, of course, been some success stories - though many
of them had already been going before the Big Society was dreamed
up, and will continue long after it has been consigned to the
dumping-ground of government initiatives. But, most significantly -
since it lies at the heart of Big Society ambitions - the plan for
5000 Community Organisers, intended to facilitate projects, has
been scaled back to a mere 500. At the same time, a charity such as
Citizens UK, whose application for money was turned down by the Big
Society fund, admits that it prefers working outside government
influence, and away from inexperienced grant managers. It is the "I
told you so" T-shirts of groups such as these that shine with
greatest lustre.
There is a similar sense of the predictable about the issue
reported by Carrie Gracie in Assignment (World Service,
Thursday), even if the details are extraordinary in their cruelty.
China has been experiencing a massive growth in Christianity over
the past decade; and the expansion of the house-church movement has
encouraged the sorts of cults that governments and church leaders
have been forced to confront since the birth of Christianity.
In May, at a McDonald's in eastern China, a woman was beaten to
death by a gang who announced themselves as disciples of the Church
of the Almighty God. The gang leader declared later: "She was a
demon. We had to destroy her." The Church holds that God, in the
form of a Chinese woman, has returned to earth, and is bringing the
apocalypse.
All very disturbing; and I can understand the official Christian
Church's desire to warn its followers against the wiles of the
cult. Nevertheless, the tone of Gracie's commentary was starting to
sound a little bit paranoid for a level-headed BBC reporter: when
you look into the eyes of a fellow Christian worshipper in church,
are you looking into the eyes of The Cult?