New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
UK >

Church censures prison-like detention

by Paul Wilkinson

Posted: 21 Nov 2014 @ 12:19


Click to enlarge

Credit: PA

Caption: Opposition: Movement for Justice protesters on the steps of the Home Office call for an end to illegal Fast Track deportations and the freeing of detainees arrested for protesting them, in August

Credit: PA

Credit: PA

Caption: Opposition: Movement for Justice protesters on the steps of the Home Office call for an end to illegal Fast Track deportations and the freeing of detainees arrested for protesting them, in August

THE holding of asylum-seekers in conditions more like prison, with no obvious end to their detention, is causing stress and insecurity, an official C of E submission has told the Government.

In a submission to a parliamentary inquiry into immigration detention, the Mission and Public Affairs Council of the Archbishops' Council says: "While not opposed to detention in principle, we recognise its severe impact on people and families, and want to ensure that conditions are humane. We believe that Immigration Removal Centres [IRCs] should be as little as possible like prisons."

It points out that accommodation built in the past ten years at Harmondsworth, Colnbrook, and at Brook House, Gatwick, are "not just prison-like, they look like a prison - harsh straight lines, built to high-security standards, bare of anything to soften the feel of the interior.

"It sounds like a prison - large echoing open wings. It feels like a prison - the attempts to call the places where the detainees sleep a 'room' is confounded by the fact that they are manifestly cells. The toilets have no seats, just a solid steel bowl. . . That toilet is inside the cell. In many cases, the detainees . . . have to eat in those cells."

The submission also expresses concern that the Inspectorate of Prisons no longer carries out a "safety survey" among detainees. It says: "We normally think of safety in detention as a matter of not fearing assault, intimidation, discrimination. However, what detainees consistently reported as most likely to make them feel unsafe was the lack of certainty about their case."

An automatic bail hearing after seven and then 35 days - as provided for by law in 1999, but never brought into effect - would help, the submission says. It also suggests that the lack of a legal time-limit is adding to the backlog of cases. "There is little pressure on case-workers to progress cases as quickly as possible. The monthly letters sent to each detainee about their continuing detention often seem to record little or no activity since the previous month."

The submission insists that faith provision should continue as it has in the past. "Faith is for many people held in detention a very important part of their resources for enduring the experience," it says.

Charity calls for end to child detention. A report published this week stated that 203 immigrant children were detained in England last year, including 70 aged under five.

The report, State of Children's Rights in England 2014, from the charity Children's Rights Alliance for England, calls for an end to the detention of children and the locking up of parents.

It says that the Home Office is considering using physical force to remove asylum-seeking and migrant children from the UK, in breach of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. The Convention also states that children should never be separated from parents for the purposes of immigration control.

The research and policy manager at the charity Bail for Immigration Detainees, Sarah Campbell, said: "The psychological distress experienced by children in immigration detention is well documented. Children who are split from detained parents describe losing weight, having nightmares, crying frequently, and becoming deeply unhappy.

"We urge the Government to implement this report's recommendations without delay."

Job of the week

Archdeacon of Tonbridge

South East

Diocese of Rochester OUR ARCHDEACONS: SHAPING THE CHURCH FOR MISSION The Bishop of Rochester seeks an ARCHDEACON OF TONBRIDGE to serve an Archdeaconry comprising the towns and villages o...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

Rather more than a hosepipe ban

Rather more than a hosepipe ban

The international links between dioceses are raising awareness of the effects of climate change overseas, says Huw Spanner  Subscribe to read more

Top comment

No longer content to pray, pay, and obey

The Synod’s rejection of the Bishops’ report was the result of shifting power dynamics, says John Saxbee  Subscribe to read more

Wed 1 Mar 17 @ 11:56
Balloons and seeds: Pentecost initiative launches new resources @thykingdom_come

Wed 1 Mar 17 @ 10:13
Martin Wright urges the Justice Secretary to take a more effective approach to the prisons crisis