From the Revd Brian Surtees
Sir, - The questioning of a diocesan bishop about historic
allegations of sexual offending raises much legitimate concern. As
a priest and former probation officer, I have shared the anxiety
and, sometimes, despair of men facing similar allegations, and
waiting for long periods before decisions about prosecution are
reached. The investigative process is often complex and delay may
be inevitable.
What is less unavoidable is the absence of any duty of care to
the person facing investigation, who will typically be left without
any support, because the nature of the allegations is shameful, and
typical advice from legal representatives is to say nothing to
anyone, and let the police prove the allegations if they can.
Family stress and relationship breakdown are obvious results of
investigations of this kind. While it may be felt that a lack of
proceedings can indicate a "clearing of the suspect's name", this
is not really the case when proceedings are simply discontinued,
often with a clear indication that the inquiry may be resumed.
Of more concern to Christian ministers should be the incidence
of mental breakdown and suicide as a result of these kinds of
investigation among people who feel unable to share their situation
with others or gain access to the kind of support needed to cope
with a significant life crisis that may often have come without
warning.
Public opinion is rightly and justifiably against people who
offend against children or vulnerable people; but the Church has a
responsibility to the accused as well as the offended-against.
Pastoral help and appropriate support can come from various
sources, but is often not easily available to people who feel
deeply ashamed of the investigation, irrespective of any guilt or
responsibility they may feel.
Practice may vary across the nation, but it would be very good
to see access to confidential support and pastoral care made
available with an easy-access contact point, so that crucial
spiritual and human needs can be met without detriment to
investigative and judicial processes.
BRIAN SURTEES
13 Bowes Drive
Ongar, Essex CM5 9AU