THERE are advantages to having a boring national anthem. We in
the UK do not have to stand around for minutes on end as an
over-ambitious chanteuse croons endless ornamental fantasias around
the melody of "God save the Queen". But spare a thought for our
cousins across the Atlantic, who, at the start of every major
sporting event, have to endure "The Star-Spangled Banner", gilded
to the point of collapse by wannabe-Whitney Houstons.
The problem is, "The Star-Spangled Banner" is a pretty good
tune. Too long, of course; and with a range far too wide to be
suited to crowd singing. But for the solo singer, it is the
ultimate power ballad; and the assertion of power - cultural,
political, and military - is what this song has also come to
represent.
In O Say Can You See? (Radio 4, Tuesday of last week),
Erica Wagner provided a potted history of the song, as well as a
survey of interpretations from the mainstream to the
counter-cultural; ,eginning and ending with the Jimi Hendrix
version, in which the rockets and bombs of the lyrics are conjured
up through the frenzied timbres of the electric guitar.
Nobody had a good word to say about the poetry of Francis Scott
Key; but the tune has a much better pedigree, originally known in
Britain as the tune "To Anacreon in Heaven", by John Stafford
Smith. In its ascent to national-anthem status it had to fight off
several contenders. How differently we might perceive American
foreign policy if its totemic song was, for instance, "Yankee
Doodle".
How we, as liberal Europeans, regard the United States is
mirrored in the way we respond to the concept of "the land of the
free" and "home of the brave". When do "civil liberties" turn into
degenerate libertarianism? The case of Carey McWilliams, as told in
Outlook (World Service, Thursday of last week) is one that
walks the tightrope between the two; for Mr McWilliams, from Fargo,
North Dakota, is the first blind person in the US to hold a gun
licence. In fact, he owns a small arsenal, including an AK-47, and
is happy to admit to "packing" more or less all the time. Land of
the brave - or the foolhardy, one might reasonably ask.
Depending on your point of view, this is either "God bless
America" for its progressive attitude, or it is another case of the
loopy US gun laws. Mr McWilliams came across as a nice young man:
good to his family, and level-headed - except for the time when he
pulled his gun on a car driver who was bothering him; and the fact
that he has been dealing with "confidence issues". But he prom-ises
never to pull a trigger unless he is at point-blank range.
Somehow, I don't think Mr McWilliams is going to be voting for
Hillary Clinton, if, as expected, she stands for President next
time round. On Woman's Hour (Radio 4, Thursday of last
week), she was saying nothing, preferring to talk about her new
book, Hard Choices.
Mrs Clinton is adept at product placement, and, in every answer
to Jenni Murray, she managed to fit in those title words. By the
time it came to the Lewinsky question, we might have all joined in:
Forgiveness is (all together now!) a hard choice.