Our parsonage house dates to the 1560s, but the diocese
now wishes to sell it, and replace it with a modern house that is
easier to maintain. Is there any way to raise funds and bring the
house up to modern standards? It is close to the church tower; so I
am sure it will be difficult to sell, and thus may be attractive
only to us.
THIS letter highlights the struggle for working resources over
valuable assets. The value of your parsonage house to local people
is undoubted - and not predominantly for its financial value. It is
close to being as foundational to your history as the church
itself.
Of the two points of view ex-pressed in your email, that of the
diocese is undoubtedly about stewardship. Old houses, often dreaded
by clergy whose stipends are inadequate for heating draughty old
houses, are often of disproportionately high value. The British do
love their historic houses. And old vicarages often have large
gardens. Dioceses are constantly being challenged to make better
sense of their finances and put people at the top of the list; so
houses are often sold.
Over the past couple of decades, the legal requirement that the
Church Commissioners should build up an appropriate pension-pot has
resulted in dioceses' having to find clergy salaries and contribute
to their pensions. In the past, that was all covered by the Church
Commissioners' funds.
So all sorts of creative approaches are considered, but parishes
now have to contribute all or some of their clergy salaries, and
contribute to the administrative cost of the diocese. Numbers of
clergy have fallen drastically, as those who retire are not
replaced in the overall numbers. It is not only a question of
suitable candidates: the Church could not find money for many
more.
It is some time since dioceses took over ownership of all clergy
houses, in order to maintain them to a better standard than that
managed by parishes. Although there was no consideration at the
time that these might become assets ripe for disposal, we have
moved in that direction. Most dioceses are selling financially
valuable vicarages and replacing them more modestly, as there are
few ways to recoup value from these assets by other means. And this
is all to meet the challenges of maintaining church life and
reaching out in mission. As in the case of your church, we may
regret this. We love what has been ours, and what represents the
solidity of our locus of faith.
Is there anything you can do? I do not know of a programme or
grant stream to defend ancient vicarages. But that does not mean
that there isn't one. You might see if the Architectural Heritage
Fund has ideas, or might be able to help you set up a "Friends of
X Parsonage House" fund in order to buy it from the
diocese. You would still be charged with its maintenance, and the
diocese might still use the funds to buy another house for your
vicar. Would you keep the house for a curate, or something
else?
It is a conundrum about which you might gather a group of
like-minded people - perhaps including a representative from the
diocesan property department - to brainstorm the possibilities and
likelihoods. It would be good to hear of a parish's coming up with
an innovative idea in the face of the financial pressures we are
all living with.
Send your questions and issues to
maggiedurran@virginmedia.com.