THE usual problem this week: I write when all the church news,
such as it is, will be old by the time you read this. In
particular, all of the writhings around gay marriage ought to have
been settled.
So, to set them all in proportion, some news of the National
Secular Society. Not all that much has been heard from this
tireless organisation since Pope Benedict's visit to the UK failed
on every count to live up to the billing promised it by the
NSS.
I still have up on my personal blog Terry Sanderson's comment
from the autumn of 2010: "Andrew Brown says that the NSS's
prediction of a cost of £20 million for the papal visit is
'risible'. . . I hadn't realised just how barking Mr Brown is."
Woof. The total cost was £10 million, with security costing
around £1.5 million.
Since then, the NSS has scaled down its assault on the cost, if
not the evils, of religion, and on Sunday it appeared outraged by
£3. This is what atheists and, indeed, agnostics and pagans must
pay if they go shopping in Woking on a Sunday without getting their
tickets cancelled in a church.
Owen Bowcott in The Guardian quoted Keith Porteous
Wood, executive director of the NSS: "The equal treatment of all,
regardless of belief or non-belief, is a key secular principle. We
have launched this challenge to preferential treatment of
worshippers because it is neither legitimate nor lawful for local
government to favour the activity of any faith (or non-faith) group
through tax-funded subsidies."
I think I'd admire him more if he said it was not the principle
of the thing: it was the large cappuccino that he had forgone which
upset him. Woking Council is contesting the suit, on the grounds
that there is a benefit to the community from people's attending
services, equivalent, I assume, to at least £3.01 a head. It's nice
to put a figure on these things.
THE other story of petty anti-religious sentiment came from
The Independent, which reports that Orthodox Jews have
been forced from their summer camp at the University of Aberystwyth
by a ruling against candles.
"This summer, university authorities have said the holidaymakers
are no longer allowed to light candles in the Pentre Jane Morgan
campus of more than 100 properties as they have done every Friday
night to usher in Shabbat - the Jewish day of rest.
"One holidaymaker, Mrs Brander, said: 'We have found a holder to
make each candle safer. We offered to discuss it with the fire
brigade, but the university was not interested.'
"A spokesman for Aberystwyth University said it had taken legal
advice and consulted its own health and safety advisors and fire
brigade. 'The university . . . would be delighted to welcome this
group back, as long as they are able to sign our terms and
conditions,' he said." This might just be a case of bureaucratic
silliness, but I suspect something nastier.
THE Telegraph, meanwhile, had a piece of rather
discomfiting original reporting by Andrew Gilligan, examining the
figure widely accepted of 212 "anti-Muslim incidents" since the
murder of Drummer Lee Rigby. "Yet the unending 'cycle of violence'
against Muslims, the unprecedented 'wave of attacks' against them
from strangers in the street, the 'underlying Islamophobia in our
society' - all turn out to be yet more things we thought we knew
about Woolwich that are not really supported by the evidence.
"Tell Mama confirmed to The Sunday Telegraph that about
120 of its 212 'anti-Muslim incidents' - 57 per cent - took place
only online. They were offensive postings on Twitter or Facebook,
or comments on blogs: nasty and undesirable, certainly, but some
way from violence or physical harm and often, indeed, legal. Not
all the offending tweets and postings, it turns out, even
originated in Britain."
Only 17 of the cases involved individuals' being physically
targeted. There is history behind this story: Tell Mama has links
with the East London Mosque, which Andrew Gilligan has written
about in the past. And there is widespread prejudice against
Muslims in this country. None the less, it suggests that the most
important response to the Woolwich atrocity was not a wave of
anti-Muslim attacks, but the York mosque that disarmed criticism by
inviting strangers in for tea.
Oh dear. I have run out of space to say all the important and
original things about gay marriage which I had planned.