*** DEBUG END ***

Synod votes to explore Option One on women bishops

08 July 2013

by Ed Thornton, Madeleine Davies, Gavin Drake and Glyn Paflin in York


Man of the match: many of the speakers said "I agree with Pete"

Man of the match: many of the speakers said "I agree with Pete"

THE General Synod has asked for new legislation to be drafted to enable women to be bishops. After a long debate on Monday morning and afternoon, it carried a motion from the House of Bishops embodying Option One ( News, 31 May), which was amended so as to specify the addition of a mandatory grievance procedure for parishes, and to urge that "facilitated conversations" continue to be used during the legislative process.

Amendments seeking to make provision for opponents by Measure or regulations made under Canon, "for co-provincial provision for alternative episcopal oversight", and to retain resolutions A and B for parish churches combined with a new Act of Synod, all fell.

But many speakers responded positively to a suggestion from the Bishop of Willesden, the Rt Revd Pete Broadbent, that for this legislation the Synod should dispense with a Revision Committee, which could be "awful", he said, as in the way it had unpicked the previous legislation, and instead have an enlarged Steering Committee, which would include "people from pressure groups and no groups at all". This, he hoped, would break the deadlock. Members who agreed with him included the phrase "I agree with Pete", at his invitation, in their speeches.

Voting was at times close in the House of Laity. Although Synod members spoke of moving away from previous patterns of debate, in fact several votes were taken by the Synod dividing into Houses. The motion was carried by 319 votes to 84, with 22 abstentions.

Speaking to reporters after the vote, the Archbishop of Canterbury said: "We came to a grinding halt last November. We've got some momentum back into the process."

Archbishop Welby conceded that there "is not two-thirds in each House. There is a strong desire to get it done. . . It is going to take a little while, [and we are] going to have to go on working at it. There has been such a shift in mood over the last six months, but as ever I remain extremely optimistic."

He described it as an "electrified ring-fence process, which should give people enough assurance of provision to be able to stay within the Church". 

Speaking during the debate, Dr Paula Gooder (Birmingham) said that members of the Synod might have noticed that on 20 November, at the end of the debate ( News, 23 November), she had not been "ecstatically happy". On reflection, this was because she had felt that she had seen "us mauling our own small part of the body of Christ. I felt as though we were savaging each other. I want to say, we must never do that again. We have a chance now to grasp a new future." Option One provided a different way of doing things, she said. It could be "robust".

But Vivienne Goddard (Blackburn) warned the Synod: "We are going to end up revisiting what we have done up to now . . . knowing that it is not acceptable to a third of the House of Laity." And Canon Wealands Bell (Lichfield) said, in a maiden speech, that Saturday's discussions had shown him that "there is no trust". It was impossible to create it by removing assurances previously given. 

The Bishop of Gibraltar in Europe, Dr Geoffrey Rowell, making his last Synod speech on the subject, said: "So often we do not hear each other, because we start from different ecclesiological premises." He hoped that facilitated discussions would bring these out into the open.

WATCH said in a statement that it was "pleased that the House of Bishops' preferred option received overwhelming support from the General Synod. . . The positive experience of the facilitated conversations was reflected in the tone of the debates. WATCH remains committed to full engagement with the ongoing process." 

The Catholic Group in General Synod said in a statement that it welcomed "the clear commitment of the General Synod to make provision for all in the Church of England". It was "fully supportive of a new kind of process involving facilitated conversations", as outlined by Bishop Broadbent.

It continued: "It is clear, from the voting on a number of amendments, that the amended Option One will need a considerable amount of further work in order to build a sufficient consensus for when it comes to the Synod for Final Approval in 2015."

Canon Margaret Swinson told the Synod on Tuesday morning that the Appointments Committee, which she chairs, had met on Monday night "in order to appoint a Steering Committee to take charge of the preparation of draft legislation to enable the ordination of women to the episcopate in accordance with the motion passed by the General Synod".

Mindful of Bishop Broadbent's suggestion and the amendment urging "facilitated discussions" to continue, the Committee had invited the Archbishop of Canterbury's director of reconciliation, David Porter, "to join the meeting to provide specialist advice on how to give effect to the Synod's intentions - in particular, the appropriate size of the Steering Group." 

The Committee agreed to issue invitations to 15 members of the Synod, representing a breadth of views, to take part in preparatory work. The names of the Steering Group would be published as soon as all those who had been invited had responded and the membership had been finally agreed, she said.

See this Friday's Church Times for full coverage.


Browse Church and Charity jobs on the Church Times jobsite

Forthcoming Events


Church Times/RSCM:

Festival of Faith and Music

26 - 28 April 2024

See the full programme on the festival website. 

Early bird tickets available


Intercultural Church for a Multicultural World

28 May 2024

A Church Times/Church House Publishing webinar

Tickets are FREE


Church Times/Modern Church:

A Political Faith?

Monday 3 June 2024

This panel will explore where Christians have come to in terms of political power and ask, where should we go next?

Online tickets available


Church Times/Modern Church:

Participating in Democracy

Monday 10 June 2024

This panel will explore the power of voting, and power beyond voting.

Online tickets available


Green Church Awards

Closing date: 30 June 2024

Read more details about the awards


Welcome to the Church Times


To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)