THE Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill cleared the committee stage
in the Lords this week.
The Bishop of Ripon & Leeds, the Rt Revd John Packer, moved
an amendment to the Education Act so that a faith school could
"teach about the nature of marriage and its importance for family
life and the bringing up of children . . . in accordance with the
tenets of the relevant religion or religious denomination".
Homophobic bullying, he said, "must have no place in church or
any other schools", and "discrimination on grounds of sexual
orientation is usually expressly forbidden within a school's code
of conduct."
But: "Within that atmosphere . . . church schools must
nevertheless be in a position to teach the nature of marriage in a
way that is in accordance with the tenets of the Church of England.
The distinctive Christian ethos of church schools will be
undermined unless that position is accommodated."
The Equalities Minister, Lady Stowell, said that, although the
Government believed that the necessary protection already existed,
"we are discussing it with the Churches and we will . . . continue
to consider it."
The Bishop of Leicester, the Rt Revd Timothy Stevens, introduced
an amendment to clarify that expressing the view that marriage was
"the union of one man with one woman" would not be considered
discrimination or harassment.
He was not, he said, seeking to introduce "a charter to vocally
agitate in the workplace". The amendment would "give reassurance
and legal protection . . . to many who share an understanding of
the Churches and other faiths, and those of no faith, about what
they believe marriage to be. . .
"At root, this amendment is largely about establishing cultural
norms and expectations about what will continue to be acceptable in
terms of public discourse about marriage. . . We cannot expect
those cultural assumptions and norms to change overnight, or at the
speed at which legislation may emerge."
Lady Stowell said that the Government was working with the
Equality and Human Rights Commission to "inform public authorities
of the absolute rights and freedoms of people to express their
religious beliefs".
Both Bishops withdrew their amendments before a vote.
A government amendment, which the Lords accepted, will change
the Public Order Act so that "any discussion or criticism of
marriage which concerns the sex of the parties to marriage shall
not be taken of itself to be threatening or intended to stir up
hatred."
The Bill returns to the Lords for its report stage on 8 July. A
number of peers who withdrew amendments indicated that they would
reintroduce them unless their concerns were addressed by
amendments.