THE Commissary Court of
Canterbury has given permission for work to restart on an extension
to a church in Kent after hearing that archaeological remains would
be unaffected.
St Mary's, Kenardington,
near Ashford, was rebuilt after being partially destroyed by
lightning in 1559. The church now plans to erect a "pentice", or
covered walkway, linking the original circular tower to the church,
and to demolish a blocked-up archway.
When the
Commissary-General, Morag Ellis QC, made a site visit to the church
last month to consider a faculty application, she was "surprised
and disturbed" to discover that work had already begun, and ordered
it to stop (News, 24
May).
In a new judgment,
however, issued on Wednesday, Ms Ellis said that the work can go
ahead: "It appears that much of any archaeological interest in the
area of the footprint of the pentice was lost as a result of works
undertaken some time ago."
The judgment indicates
that archaeologists had concluded that the proposed floor levels in
the new development would "rest well above" any limited remaining
intact deposits.
"The effect of unblocking
the arches in the north wall of the nave, and the east wall of the
tower, would be to reunite the nave and tower by the construction
of the new extension on the footprint of part of the original
building," Ms Ellis said in her judgment. "I consider that this
linkage would be historically appropriate, and would enable a
better appreciation of the way in which the church was laid out
before the 16th-century fire."
She praised the proposals
as "an ingenious design solution", saying that "the church's
isolated position, and lack of modern facilities, clearly
constitute severe limitations on the parish's ability to make use
of the building to serve the needs of its people," and that "the
parish has sought to find a new way in which it can utilise this
historic asset in mission.
"Preservation of the
church as it is might seem superficially appealing from an
aesthetic perspective, but I am entitled and obliged to have regard
to the mission of the church, and, indeed, the long-term viability
of the building to continue in its historic use as a place of
worship."
Ms Ellis said that the Rector of Kenardington, the Revd Roderick
Whateley, had written a "courteous letter" to apologise for
starting work before a faculty had been granted, and that she had
accepted his apology.