GOOD Queen Bess has one specific virtue to her credit which was
noted in the first episode of David Starkey's Music and
Monarchy (BBC2, Saturdays): what we now take for granted as
the entire tradition of Anglican church music survived and
developed thanks to her, personally.
While most of those who wielded power in Church and State longed
for a thorough rooting out of anything that could be considered
even slightly Catholic - such as choirs, music, and organs - and
churches, cathedrals, and colleges were reduced to intoning
doggerel Genevan psalms, she insisted that her Chapel Royal created
a reformed professional English church music that carried on
pre-Reformation levels of musical skill and complexity. Worse, she
patronised and protected the two greatest 16th- century English
composers, Tallis and Byrd, even though they were known
recusants.
The prefacing of this documentary's title with the name "David
Starkey", intended to whet the viewing appetite of middle England,
has for me almost exactly the opposite effect: his somewhat
hectoring tone leaves me cold. Here, however, he is absolutely
terrific, telling a story that I suspect is largely unknown.
Although his avowed subject is music, this first programme was
as much about religion itself. The most important component of
Henry V's army on campaign in France, he averred, was its Chapel
Royal: the canons and choir with full liturgical panoply, offering
high mass daily to invoke God's blessing on their endeavour. The
monarch's response to the great victory at Agincourt was to
increase the size of his choir to an unheard-of 50 singers, and add
more antiphons to their liturgy. His composer John Dunstable
created new music that was admired and copied throughout
Europe.
Henry VI founded Eton College as a huge chantry for the singing
of masses for soul of his father; the Eton Choir Book records music
of greater complexity than any known on the continent. Henry VIII
refused to see the consequences of his destruction of the
monasteries, thinking that his personal love of music would secure
its liturgical survival; but Edward VI completed the logical task:
colleges were closed, choirs disbanded, musical manuscripts burned
or cut up.
This is no dry lecture: the musical examples are sung by the
choirs that are the successors of those for whom it was originally
composed, in the original buildings. Starkey has created a
beautiful celebration of our heritage, and reminded us that its
survival once hung by the slenderest thread.
There was a somewhat different take on the past in a new series,
Family Tree (BBC2, Tuesday of last week). Tom is convinced
that the impressive field marshal whose 1905 photo is left to him
by his deceased great-aunt must be his great-grandfather, thus
providing the self-respect that he so clearly lacks. In the event,
his forebear was not the subject of the snap, but the photographer
- and a Chinaman at that. This is a gentle comedy of failure and
discomfort. It has the effect of making us, the viewers, feel that,
in comparison, we are sorted out and normal.