A FORMAL complaint brought
by the Board of Deputies of British Jews against the Revd Dr
Stephen Sizer, Vicar of Christ Church, Virginia Water, has been
resolved through conciliation under the Clergy Discipline Measure
(CDM).
In October last year, the
Board of Deputies lodged a formal complaint against Dr Sizer under
the CDM, alleging that he had made anti-Semitic statements and
published links to anti-Semitic websites (News, 2
November). Before this complaint, a review by the Crown
Prosecution Service concluded that Dr Sizer had not committed any
criminal offence (News, 16 March and
4 May
2012).
In May, the Bishop of
Guildford, the Rt Revd Christopher Hill, appointed two conciliators
to at-tempt to resolve the complaint.Conciliation is one of the
outcomes set out in the CDM. On Wednesday, Bishop Hill confirmed
that the conciliation process, which included a face-to-face
meeting of the two parties, had resolved the complaint.
"I welcome the spirit of
this agreement as a positive step towards Jewish-Christian
understanding," he said. "I am also pleased to take this
opportunity once again to emphasise how important it is for the
Church to stand firm against all forms of prejudice and the evils
of racial hatred."
The report of the
conciliation states: "Without accepting the substance of the
complaint, Dr Sizer regrets that on occasions his use of language
has caused offence to some and agrees that he should have reflected
on his choice of words more carefully. The content of certain
websites having been drawn to his attention, Dr Sizer also accepts
that he should have taken more care before linking to them.
"He does not accept that
this amounts to conduct unbecoming or inappropriate to a clerk in
Holy Orders.
"Dr Sizer maintains his
opposition to anti-Semitism, and maintains that he did not link to
the websites in question in order to introduce his readers to
anti-Semitic material."
Both sides have agreed that
"freedom of speech within the law is of fundamental importance",
and that "exercise of this freedom may cause offence, but is best
carried out while demonstrating care and sensitivity over the use
of language."
The report states that Dr
Sizer has agreed to ensure that three people will read his website
and blog in order to check the content and monitor any links to
websites. He will also "reflect on any points concerning his
publications which are made to him (preferably privately) and
respond promptly to identifiable critics".
On Wednesday, the vice-
president of the Board of Deputies, Jonathan Arkush, said: "The
outcome has demonstrated that the Board of Deputies, the community
and very many Christians were right to feel very deep concern about
Revd Sizer."
Dr Sizer said: "The
complaint alleged that I had made anti-Semitic statements, and had
deliberately introduced my readers to anti-Semitic websites. I have
always maintained that these allegations were untrue, and am
confident that I would have been vindicated had I been forced to
contest them at a clergy disciplinary tribunal."
Social media brought with it
the risk, he said, that "we might publish our thoughts without
adequately reflecting on our choice of words or how they might be
interpreted. I will do all I can to guard against this risk in the
future."
He said: "I care passionately about the safety of the Jewish
people and the right of Israel to exist within internationally
agreed borders. I have always opposed racism, anti-Semitism, and
Holocaust-denial, as well as Islamophobia and the denial of the
Palestinian right to self-determination, and will continue to do
so."