"YORKSHIRE schools" were, for Dickens and his contemporaries,
particularly shameful blots on the face of British public life -
sordid places, where illegitimate and unwanted children could be
sent in the secure knowledge that they would hardly reach
adulthood.
Nowadays, in certain sections of the media, it is, of course,
the teachers who are thought to be unlikely to escape unscathed
from a sustained encounter with the feral offspring of this
benighted region. Educating Yorkshire (Channel 4,
Thursdays), the distillation of a year's fly-on-the-wall filming of
Thornhill Community Academy, Dewsbury, presents the true picture:
challenging students - irreverent, disrespectful, and rumbustious,
but full of life, and surely of far greater potential than they
themselves realise.
Last week's episode told the story of Jack, a troubled
13-year-old, seemingly incapable of sitting still, or keeping his
explosive temper - the "Olympic champion of [bad] behaviour
points". The question was whether he was fit to be in a mainstream
school at all. But the stars of the show were the staff, displaying
amazing reserves of patience and hope, certain that, if only they
persevered, something could unlock Jack's abilities. Eventually, he
was sent to the school's "inclusion centre". And it worked: a month
passed without incident, and he was accepted for the history
stream, his favourite subject.
The process involved a parade of things from which I normally
run a mile: sentimentality, jargon, cliché. But nothing could be
more admirable than the patient faith in the power of education to
give someone a decent start in life, and the prospect of future
achievement.
Always keen to try something new, I tuned in last Saturday to
BBC Parliament. Home at the Top was an evening devoted to
the 50th anniversary of the choosing, against all expectation, as
leader of the Tory party and Prime Minister in place of Harold
Macmillan, of Alec Douglas-Home, 14th Earl.
The fun for me was watching ancient history that, paradoxically,
I remember quite well. The heart of the evening was a repeat of the
Panorama discussion, chaired by Robin Day, that was
broadcast that evening. Television has now been around long enough
to give us a reprise of half a century ago, exactly as we saw it
then -something no previous generation has experienced.
In fact, if you discount the fact that the technology then
available made everything seem, in contrast to today's Technicolor,
irredeemably grey, and, if you ignore the style - everyone in a
suit, everyone addressed as "Mr So-and-so" - I am not sure that the
substance and the sentiments were different from what we would get
in a round-table discussion today.
The most startling aspect was the refusal of the Labour
representative to say anything negative about Macmillan: he just
said how much everyone wished him a full recovery of health. Of
course, the scenario has dated beyond recognition - nowadays, we
take it for granted that our Prime Minister will have been educated
at something like Thornhill Academy: surely no one in the 21st
century could imagine a PM from Eton and Oxford?