WE HEARD the terrible story, once again last week, of teenagers'
taking their own lives after online pressure. Last Friday the
funeral was held of Hannah Smith, a 14-year-old who was found
hanged after being bullied on the internet. She had posted a
question about her eczema on the ask.fm site, and received
anonymous answers that were abusive and filled with hate. On the
same day, the death of 17-year-old Daniel Perry was announced. He
had jumped from the Forth Bridge, after being blackmailed over an
explicit internet video.
The question whether it is time to stop the culture of online
anonymity is one that the Church needs to engage with, if it is to
make sense to its younger members. Most children have a mobile
phone by the time they are about eight - not least because it is a
safety device that enables parents to allow greater freedom.
Facebook accounts are supposed to be opened only after the age of
13, but most of the 11-year-old pupils whom I teach use Facebook or
Kick, Keek, Vine, Snapchat, WhatsApp, ask.fm, or Twitter.
With all these options, there are a range of excitements for a
child, promising relief from boredom, raucous fun, the lure of
celebrity, and a pushing of boundaries.
What all of them have in common, however, is the fact that the
children type messages in the seclusion of their own room, to an
audience of their own imagination. Even those who write regular
messages to their friends admit to getting the nuances wrong, or
misunderstanding what is being meant. How much greater is this
effect when you are writing to a stranger?
Anonymity also allows children to try out different identities,
or to vent one of their many different moods of anger or
unhappiness. But this communication is not a dialogue: it is
talking at an unknown other.
In the Bible, "knowing someone" is a big deal. As a phrase, it
is used to refer to sexual relations, thus transforming the act of
intercourse into a means of communication. Crucially for this
debate, God says: "I have called you and know you by name. You are
mine" (Isaiah 43.1). The Christian message of love is that God has
created us, and knows each one of us individually.
As a school chaplain, I find that this is the message that has
the most resonance for the pupils I preach to. And no wonder: they
live in a world where communication is not about conversation, but
about one-sided, anonymous text.
I think that the most important lesson we can take from these
recent and similar teenage suicides is that of a need for a more
old-fashioned kind of communication: one where parents and
children, and those in schools, youth groups, and churches talk to
each other. It is about creating a climate of openness and kindness
which will enable children and adolescents to speak more freely
about what is troubling them.
One result of the screen-world we live in can be a strangely
companionable silence, as we all sit in the same room and interact
with our individual gadgets: we are left with a surreal situation
in which we are communicating all the time, but not with the human
being who is sitting next to us.
It is strange to think that sites such as ask.fm are
flourishing, while we are with our teenagers without asking them
anything at all. Of course, communication can be one of the great
difficulties with adolescents: it is almost as if they wilfully
block any attempt that we make to speak with them. Diplomatic
language becomes bellicose too easily. So, as adults, we take the
easy way out, and say nothing, leaving them to their own
devices.
But a climate of openness and basic kindness recognises that
what teenagers are desperate to do is to find themselves, to be
important, and to be known. This is the quest of all our lives, and
it begins with the sense of being precious and being loved by
God.
Children and adolescents are good at knowing what other people
think of them. Ask them about someone's relationship, and they can
tell you immediately.
We have heard much in recent months about the online world of
predatory adults, and this is an area that can now be addressed by
the law. But these recent suicides remind us that there is also an
online world that children inhabit alone, because adults have
little understanding of it, and often little interest in it.
Meanwhile, the rules are being made by Ralph and Jack; and Piggy is
going to die.
Steve Biddulph writes in Raising Boys and Raising
Girls (Harper Thorsons, 1997, 2010 and 2013) that children
need their mother from birth to seven years, their father from
seven to 14, and an uncle, aunt, godmother, or trusted teacher from
14 onwards. As Churches, we can include this in our discussion with
godparents, and encourage mentoring between our twentysomethings
and teenagers.
As a school chaplain, one of the first things I am asked in a
conversation with a student is whether it is confidential. "No," is
my careful reply, because sometimes people share things that could
mean harm to themselves or other people. In these circumstances, I
tell them, we need to work out a way together in which we can tell
other people about it. Every pupil I have ever seen will listen to
this, and then launch into the most hair-raising details about his
or her private life.
The online world has not killed communication - quite the
opposite. Teenagers want to talk, and want to be heard. We should
all be interested enough to ask them about their opinions, their
ideas, and their understanding of the world.
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and
the Word was God." We believe in a God who spoke the world into
existence, a God who communicates, and who can teach us how to
communicate in ways that will ultimately save us.
The Revd Dr Tess Kuin Lawton is NSM in Bampton with
Clanfield, and Chaplain of Magdalen College School in Oxford, where
she teaches all years.