THE Select Committee established to consider the draft Bill to
enable women to be consecrated as bishops in the Church in Wales
will finalise its report and recommendations by 14 June, paving the
way for a vote by the Governing Body in September.
If passed as it is currently drafted, the Bill would not come
into effect until a second Bill had been passed to provide for
those with theological objections to women in the episcopate (News, 21
September 2012).
The Archdeacon of Newport, the Ven. Jonathan
Williams, who chairs the Bill's Select Committee, said that three
amendments had been proposed by the deadline.
Under CiW procedures, the Select Committee does not decide
whether to accept the amendments, but will make recommendations on
these, and any of their own amendments. They will then be debated
during the committee stage of the Bill, which will take place in
September, as well as the final approval vote.
Archdeacon Williams said that one of the amendments "proposes
that the scheme of provision for members who, for reason of
conscience, cannot accept a female bishop, should be extended to
provide also for anyone unable to accept a male bishop."
Another amendment, he said, would remove all reference to the
second Bill, and, instead, invite the Bench of Bishops to produce a
code of practice.
The Bill was not debated by members during last week's session
of the Governing Body. Instead, members met in small groups to
consider the theological cases for and against. In addition to the
recent Church Times eight-page guide (Supplement, 18
January), members were provided with two discussion papers.
In one, the Revd Dr Rhiannon
Johnson said that the CiW has ordained women and men as
priests for more than 15 years, and that a third of its priests
were women. "It is to our credit in Wales that this has happened
without the need for an elaborate 'Berlin Wall' of structural
provisions, such as exists in England and threatens all
episcopacy.
"We have not yet tied ourselves up in knots with appeasements
and resolutions that make no one feel secure, and deepen the
divisions between us on this issue rather than allowing them a
chance to heal."
In the other paper, Canon Tudor Hughes said:
"The Church in Wales has always considered the episcopate to be a
foundational sign of its unity with the whole Church, past and
present. To alter that foundational sign of the apostolicity of the
whole Church, without the consent of the whole Church, is to do
grave damage to the ecclesial identity and self-understanding of
the Church in Wales.
"We doubt that an episcopate which no longer conforms to one of
the identifying marks of the Order of Bishops - its maleness - can
continue to be a sign of continuity, of apostolicity, of fidelity
and unity in the way the Church in Wales has hereto understood
them."
A Bill to permit women to serve as bishops was last debated by
the Governing Body in April 2008. On that occasion, it narrowly
failed to achieve a two-thirds majority in the House of Clergy (News,
4 April 2008).