EVERY year, the Church Commissioners publish bishops' accounts,
and every year now the Daily Mail bites on granite in its
attempt to find prelatical extravagance.
They do things differently in Germany, and very much better from
the point of view of the scandalmongering press. Even the
Financial Times got in on the action with the story of the
Rt Revd Franz-Peter Tebartz-van Elst, RC Bishop of Limburg.
Admittedly, the story referred to the bishop's "parish", but it
had all the juicy bits well presented: "'He's behaved like a
baroque prince of the church, said one former Limburg resident on
Thursday. 'The German Catholic church spends €100m a year on social
work in developing countries. He has spent a third of that on his
residence.'
"The soaring costs were confirmed this week by diocesan
officials, including details of a €15,000 bath installed in the
bishop's residence, constant changes in the building plans, and
top-of-the-range materials used for all the fittings. When the
project began in 2010, the total cost was put at €5.5 million. The
latest estimate is €31 million.
"To compound the indignity for the bishop, the state prosecutor
in Hamburg issued an indictment on Thursday for issuing false
affidavits to the court in a case he had brought against the
magazine Der Spiegel, over an article that
alleged he had flown first-class on a church trip to India."
It is a shame that no one here quoted Browning about the Bishop
ordering his sons to set right his tomb in St Praxed's church; for,
though no one has accused Bishop Tebartz-van Elst of having a
mistress - and I'm sure that there's no scandal about one in the
wings - it all is wonderfully reminiscent of the poem's sensuous
greed:
And I shall fill my slab of basalt
there,
And 'neath my tabernacle take my rest,
With those nine columns round me, two and two,
The odd one at my feet where Anselm stands:
Peach-blossom marble all, the rare, the ripe
As fresh-poured red wine of a mighty pulse.
Instead of the €15,000 bath in Limburg, Browning's bishop had
one of solid jasper:
My bath must needs be left behind,
alas!
One block, pure green as a pistachio-nut.
The Guardian dwelt most on his final indignity, when he
was summoned to Rome: "Wedged into an economy seat next to the
window, a disgraced bishop who spent millions on a lavish new
residence has flown on a budget airline to Rome where his future is
expected to be decided by Pope Francis."
Or, as Browning had it, "evil and brief hath been my
pilgrimage." Well, I hope it was brief - with Ryanair, you never
know - but evil, certainly. And full marks, too, to The
Guardian for illustrating one story on the scandal with the
campest picture I have ever seen of any bishop in any
denomination.
THIS was a story without any moral interest whatever. More
interesting was the story of another German Roman Catholic who
thought he was playing by the rules with much more terrible
consequences. Erich Priebke was an SS officer who took part in the
massacre of 334 hostages in some caves outside Rome. They had been
rounded up in retaliation for the deaths of 33 Germans in a
Partisan attack, and he admitted to shooting two of them personally
and ordering the deaths of many others. The admission came many
years later; for, after the war, like many Germans with his
political views, he made a home in Argentina, and lived there for
50 years until deported back to Italy, tried, and sentenced to life
imprisonment in 1996.
So, where should he be buried? Argentina does not want him back,
where he could lie beside his wife. No one in Germany wants him,
except some neo-Nazis whose enthusiasm frightens everybody else.
And the diocese of Rome is having second thoughts.
A characteristically subtle and thoughtful piece by John L.
Allen in the National Catholic Reporter lays out the
problem: "The Vicariate of Rome under Italian Cardinal Agostino
Vallini, which ad- ministers the Rome diocese in the name of the
Pope, issued a statement saying no funeral for Priebke would be
held in a Roman church."
But Allen also found a cardinal, the retired Swiss Georges
Cottier, who wanted a quiet funeral for Priebke in Rome: "In an
interview, Cottier conceded there are cases in which funerals might
be denied, but implies it ought to be rare because 'everyone needs
prayer. . . I think that if funerals were denied to everyone who
committed evil during their lives, it would be anticipating the
judgment of God,' he said."
It is sometimes a little frustrating that arguments of such
subtlety and, in fact, general interest so seldom break into the
news reporting of secular papers.