THE Bishop of Durham, the Rt
Revd Justin Welby, has joined other members of the Parliamentary
Commission on Banking Standards to question former executives of
the Swiss financial services company UBS (
News, 20 July).
The bankers were giving
evidence, on Wednesday of last week, about the Libor rate-rigging
scandal that earned a £940-million fine from the Financial Services
Authority (FSA).
Bishop Welby - who, Lord
Williams of Oystermouth suggested, would be a "far more effective
contributor" to discussions about finance - said that he had been
"stunned" to learn of the corruption at UBS. Forty-five people
there had been involved in manipulating the Libor rate between 2005
and 2010, and had shown "total disregard for proper standards", the
FSA had said.
An "internal drive for
excellence" was "almost entirely absent" at UBS, a "corrupted
organisation", Bishop Welby said. "Pervasively through the
organisation, people must have known that things were not quite
right; yet nobody objected. Where is that professional attitude
going to come from?"
The new head of investment
banking at UBS, Andrea Orcel, admitted that, across the banking
industry, "we all got probably too arrogant, too self-convinced
that things were correct the way they were. The industry needs to
change."
Bishop Welby asked Mr Orcel
why he was "the person who can turn it round", given that he was
previously employed by another bank with "massive cultural and
ethical issues", the Bank of America, which recently paid the
United States government £7.2 billion after being sued for selling
"toxic" mortgages.
Mr Orcel said that a
"limited number of people" were responsible for malpractice at UBS,
and that "many people were appalled, upset, angry that their own
reputation was dragged down by the acts of others."
On Thursday of last week,
Bishop Welby questioned Alex Wilmot-Sitwell, the former head of UBS
investment banking, who is now head of European operations at the
Bank of America, and pressed him on how "ethical construction" was
undertaken.
Mr Wilmot-Sitwell said that
there had been a "massive reinforcement of ethics and culture and
behavioural tendencies within organisations. . . There is a
recognition that there is a massive hill to climb in terms of
recovering that reputation, rebuilding integrity."
In an article for the
financial news service Bloomberg, published on Thursday of last
week, Bishop Welby wrote that he was "reluctant to cast blame" for
the collapse of the banking system, but "responsibility needs to be
taken, and structures created that lean toward virtue rather than
vice."
He suggested that the "jury is now out as to whether . . .
financial services have been a net benefit to the UK economy as a
whole". It was "virtue and leadership embedded within corporate
cultures", rather than regulations, that prevented malpractice, he
said.