IN THE Tablet there is a lengthy communication from Dom
Bede Camm, in which he tells the story of the submission of the
Caldey Community to Roman authority. Fr Camm, who himself has gone
through the process of renouncing obedience to the ancient Catholic
Church in this country, manages, though unintentionally, to reveal
the Caldey monks in a not very satisfactory light. Incidentally, he
criticizes our contention that they have acted precipitately, but
if, as he implies, their minds had been made up for a whole year,
their conduct is quite unintelligible. For they invoked the
assistance and direction of a Visitor, and to all appearances were
ready to continue in the English Church, on condition, at least,
that he allowed them to do exactly as they wished. But still, they
would have remained English Churchmen, and, if so, they obviously
could have no doubt of the validity of English Orders and of their
full possession of the Sacraments. When their Visitor directed them
to desist from certain practices, in a moment the situation was
entirely changed. They discovered that they had been living in
heresy and schism, that they had no priest among them, no
Sacraments, that possibly they had never even been baptized.
Already they have been admitted to the Roman communion by a Bishop
in partibus, with the pretended title of Bishop of
Menevia, but upon what terms we are not informed. We hope that they
did not commit the sacrilege of being rebaptized, because such a
proceeding is hopelessly irreconcilable with their readiness, only
a short time back, to stay where they were, as though the validity
of the Sacraments as hitherto administered by themselves and to
themselves were unquestioned. We think we are justified in saying
that they took the final step with no little haste.