From Andrea Hunton
Sir, - Much will be said about the resignation of Cardinal Keith
O'Brien (News, 1 March) and his
acknowledgement that his conduct had "fallen beneath the standards
expected of a priest and bishop" (News, 8
March). Much will be said by those opposed to the Roman
Catholic Church, and to Christian faith, ethics, and practice. But,
if one thing should be learnt from this, and the cases of abuse in
the RC and other Churches, it is that hierarchal ways of operating
must end.
It is when we invest too much, including power and authority, in
a select few, including politicians, media owners, journalists,
bankers, celebrities, workplace managers, and tribal leaders,
without proper transparency and accountability, that so much can go
wrong.
At this time, in the Parish and People movement and the Local
Ministry Network of the Church of England, prophetic voices are
calling for new ways of shared and collaborative leadership and
ministry in which lay people are equal partners with those who are
ordained.
As the new Archbishop of Canterbury is installed (not, I hope,
enthroned), and as a new Pope is elected, both need to take on
board, with all the clergy and people, that in the words of St
Paul, the apostle, "All have sinned and fallen short of the glory
of God," and that the way of Jesus, reflected in foot-washing on
Maundy Thursday, was to be non-hierarchical. Self-emptying and
taking the form of a servant is the Christian message - not
assuming power and authority and then misusing it; nor should we
collude in allowing one person, whether pope, bishop, ordained
minister, or secular or business leader, to take all to himself or
herself without proper, appropriate, and respectful mechanisms of
question and challenge. How many dioceses have responsive and
thorough-going complaints procedures, and actively support and
encourage whistle-blowers?
A new form of responsibility and accountability is ready to
swell up, if only ordinary people will demand and enact it.
ANDREA HUNTON
Address supplied